Nov. 16, 2026

Board Talk #18 with Sam Prior — Controversial Takes, New Info On The MoonSpray, and Why Matching Should Always Be Allowed

Board Talk #18 with Sam Prior —  Controversial Takes, New Info On The MoonSpray, and Why Matching Should Always Be Allowed
Board Talk #18 with Sam Prior —  Controversial Takes, New Info On The MoonSpray, and Why Matching Should Always Be Allowed
The Testpiece Podcast
Board Talk #18 with Sam Prior — Controversial Takes, New Info On The MoonSpray, and Why Matching Should Always Be Allowed

Boards have become a unique discipline and culture within climbing, so we created a recurring podcast focused on the latest things happening in board climbing and what it means for our sport from industry veterans and board lovers: Sam Prior of Careless Talk and Joshua Horsley the host of Testpiece.


*Patreon Bonus Content (join https://www.patreon.com/testpiece for extended cut):*

- Why Sam only boulders

- The importance of authenticity in climbing media



Join Patreon: HERE

Follow us on Instagram: HERE

Visit our podcast page: HERE

00:00 - Intro

14:17 - What Makes A Good Climber?

30:02 - The Problem With “No Matching” Boulders

40:14 - New Info On The MoonSpray

01:00:00 - Support From Patreon

01:21:58 - Hot Takes That Will Get Us Cancelled

Intro

SPEAKER_00

I lost some money on cryptocurrency once. Wise man of the world. I junk a bit, I junk a bit of the Kool Aid right in the early days. I was like, yeah, maybe there is something in this. And then I got hacked, Josh, and I lost my crypto coins.

SPEAKER_01

Welcome to the Test Piece podcast. This podcast is about all things high-level climbing. How to go from good to great. I'm your host, Joshua Horsley. I've been climbing for over 30 years. We recently updated our Patreon, and now you get exclusive content from the guests that you love. You get your episodes before everyone else, and they're ad-free. Try it out now at patreon.com slash test piece with a free seven-day trial. Okay, let's start the show.

SPEAKER_00

But the thing is, this is the thing though now, and this is like totally different. And again, um I know this is supposed to be board talk, but this is more of a general point. But something that's happening now is that it's quite funny to watch, is like being really good at climbing, not enough now. And like it's not gonna be, and increasingly it's gonna be not enough. Like, has any point in history have there been more boulders climbing the top grade at the same time? No. It isn't it's crazy that now you could climb 9A and it just like it just doesn't mean anything because there are so many other people. Obviously, it means something. I don't want to be like, you know, I'm obviously being hyperbolous, but but like it means a great deal, but it doesn't mean enough that it's gonna help get you a professional job unless you're a good communicator. So now you've kind of got to be both, which is very interesting.

SPEAKER_01

I can't remember who I was talking to, but they basically said something along the lines of that they felt bad for this one guy who is maybe late teens, early 20s, and he climbs 8C plus pretty consistently, and it's almost like the worst place to be in where they're a great climber. They probably really just want to be a professional climber and they're really good, but they're not you know that good, and there's nothing that special about them, and it's a rough spot to be in where you're literally world class, you know, you gotta be probably top 50 in the world. I don't know, maybe something like that. Doesn't matter, like doesn't matter, and yeah, just sheer difficulty unless you're I don't know, is there anyone who is now making a living off of just being the best climb, like physically, like a top climber, or do they all have kind of side gigs that you know, whether it's podcasting and or whatever?

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, I was just reading through people in my head, and they've mostly got side gigs. I can't speak for the Japanese climbers because I don't know them. But I'm thinking there must be someone. Um, someone like Adam Shahar, maybe, doesn't have any side gigs. Austin Hoyt.

SPEAKER_01

They're not making they're not making money. I I have no idea. I I I'll tell you what, Austin's not making any money from good terms, I'll tell you that much.

SPEAKER_00

Nice, Josh, nice. And here we are, just lording it over them.

SPEAKER_01

Okay, Sam, um, in true careless talk style, I feel like we're already doing the podcast, so I won't do any kind of intro or clap or professional thing. Um, but Sam, I did get a comment on one of my YouTubes that was for Ethan Pringle, and they said, Hey, you do a big disservice to your guests like Ethan when you don't introduce them. They didn't know who Ethan was. And I was like, You don't know Ethan Pringle. This guy's a legend. And so, Sam, I hate doing intros for guests. I mean, you're Sam Pryor. You do you do it when they're there?

SPEAKER_00

We wait till they left for this exact reason. Oh, dude, it's so awkward. It's like, could you imagine meeting at the board? Wait till they leave and then stitch it in. Otherwise, they have to sit there going like, hmm, yes, pick me up.

SPEAKER_01

Okay, you're the one who gives me crap about being overly professional. I feel like that's a very professional thing to do because that requires excess work after the fact. And I don't know, I like kind of just one one take it, just you know, here we are, and that's done.

SPEAKER_00

It actually creates some really awkward moments though, because Aiden and I stay on at the end to do the intro. And quite often the guest is like, bye then. And we're our podcast, it's just you hit there, we're already recording, we're recording when you leave. There's no goodbye, like you know, off pod. So we're there going like, all right, bye then. And then we just stay there waiting for them to leave. And then, like, so now we've started trying to like okay, I'll look like I'm about to click off, or like I'm, you know, I'll get up from my chair as to look like I'm about to walk away, and hope that we can bait the guest to leave so that we can jump in and do the intro. But sometimes the guest just stays there. And we have to go. Oh, um, yeah, this is this is when this is when you leave. Could you could you go? We we'd like to hang out without you. Please leave. You're not invited anymore. That's great. But no, please, no, introduce me. I'll just sit here. Gosh, no, it's too awkward, man.

SPEAKER_01

It's so awful. It's, I mean, Sam, I said, I said, you're Sam Pryor, you run Careless Talk. I feel like our audience overlap must be a hundred percent. Except for I think my mom doesn't listen to my podcast, but probably listens to your podcast. Uh and you climb unbelievably hard. You run a gym, you're on every moon climbing cool video that they do. Um, you're Sam Prior. Everyone knows you. I feel like you are a legend. I don't have to introduce you. And so I didn't want to because if we bumped into each other at the boulders, I wouldn't introduce you to myself before we start talking. And that's the vibe I always want is just as if we were climbing at the boulders together.

SPEAKER_00

It's funny, and this is a question for both of us now, Josh. Is our climbing relevant at this point? Because I was driving, driving, or driving down in front the other day, and I was like, if I just stopped climbing, would it even matter anymore? Like, I feel like if there's anything I've got left to contribute to climbing, it's nothing to do with me actually climbing now. Now it's just if I've got anything left to contribute, it's just talking on podcasts. And then when that's done, I'm done, really, isn't it? You know, that it's that I I sort of walk off into the sunset. Because I'm not, it's just, you know, these these guys try to climb again with Aiden the other day. He's so much better than me that it's like, it's is it relevant now that I'm like, you know, I'm still pretty good? Is that is that enough? It's not relevant.

SPEAKER_01

No, it does not matter. Um, because also I I think that it has this interesting spectrum, depending on the side you look at, where if you are maybe a normal climber who's been climbing a while, loves what you do, uh, you look at anything probably like eight A and up as just ridiculous. Um, you know, it's just, I'm sure Sam, if if anyone was climbing in a gym and you walked in and started climbing with them, you know, 99.9% of people would be like, whoa, uh, this guy climbs. This guy knows what he's doing. And they wouldn't know if you were you know even trying that hard. It might be like some 8A that is easy for you, or it might be an 8C that you think is impossible, but to them it would just be impressive. And then on the other side, you have guys like Aiden who are like just so far above even some of the best climbers that yeah, it it doesn't matter that much that you climb 8C or 8B plus on the regular at least, because that gap between that and consistently climbing 9A is is is really massive.

SPEAKER_00

Sorry to say, you know, yeah, just no, it is, it is definitely it is massive. Um, and it because I was thinking, like, you know, with with so many other sports, the people who talk about them are people who used to do them. You know, they're like, you know, ever tired football players or whatever sport you're talking about. They then go into podcasting because their playing days are over. But in climbing, it somehow seems maybe kind of important that the people talking about it still do it. But then it's different, isn't it? It's like, you know, doing it recreationally, but talking about it with professionals. I don't know. Like, do we need to do we need to do it?

SPEAKER_01

Well, I I just think that climbing is one of these sports that you get to do your whole life, where I did gymnastics when I was a kid, and you do not do gymnastics when you're an adult. In fact, the way gymnastics works is you do it until you're broken and then you move on. Like, and that's how did you maintain health long enough to go to the Olympics? Because that's kind of what those Olympians are. They're often, I mean, they're incredible athletes, but it's like their bodies held up and so they got a shot at, but no one's doing gymnastics at you know 40 with two kids. Uh, and so I I think it's a little different. And the way I justified my position in the climbing community at this point is that I've gone deep, like I've been obsessed. You know, I I still am obsessed, maybe not to the degree I was at 25, but you know, I've put my all into it. And I feel like there's a truth there that you can just understand what's going on at whatever level when you've at least lived it for a bit. And I think that gives us the ability to communicate with the best of the best who are still living it.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, someone put it to me once that my sort of level is yes, there's still like a group of people out there who will absolutely destroy me. But at least the people who destroy me don't have a level above them who destroy them, which is nice. At least there's at least I'm just one level of destruction down.

SPEAKER_01

I feel like that the level is so high now that it's now two levels for me. What when I was younger and climbing hard, I mean, not that I climbed that different now, I felt like I would climb with the best of the best, and I would be like, oh, I see what they're doing. That makes sense. That that's possible. I'm gonna keep digging in and and keep trying hard. But now I'm not sure that I really can even grok what is going on at the highest level. It seems so high-end compared to even five, ten years ago that yeah, I I mean you may be just a level below the top, but I'm definitely two notches.

SPEAKER_00

It's yeah, Dante's circles of hell will just gonna drift downward the older we get talking about it. But you know, sessioning with Aiden um uh in the summer, he's widened the gap, which doesn't make a lot of sense. Like he's he's got better faster than most of the other people who who I climb with. And surely he uh it should be slowing down, but he doesn't seem to be. Or, you know, no, because uh for me at my time, you know, I'm 34, I've got two kids, I'm probably not, you know, it makes sense that my rate of improvement is dipping off. But for some of these people that you know they're a lot younger than me, they're still pro-climbers, they should be improving as quickly as Aiden or faster, but he seems like he's improving faster, which is scary.

SPEAKER_01

Well, he's how old is Aiden? He's young. I mean, I was just talking about this on the latest good temps where you know Adam Andra just did Exodia, um, Jakob Schuber just did DNA, and I incorrectly said Jacob was 37. He's actually like 35. I realized where I got that number from it was when he stated he was going for the Olympics and that he would be 37 at that time. Um, but I feel like I was as strong as I ever was around 35-ish, 36-ish. So, you know, Aiden's still got plenty of runway. And yeah, I mean, do you think that he's physically getting stronger or is just more experienced about applying his strength? Is it technique? Like, how is he still leveling up?

SPEAKER_00

I think it is strength at this point. Like Aiden's technique is flawless, he doesn't really make mistakes, he climbs so well. I mean, he climbs slowly, so it's easier, I think, for him to climb really well. Um, if I'm gonna try and bring him down a notch, maybe that's how I would do it. But how does climbing slowly make you climb better? Or yeah, because he's got more time. He's got more time to nail all his moves. Um, and like the way he because he goes so slowly to hold so he can get them all perfectly.

SPEAKER_01

But that's like because he's like so strong, and it this is a a knock that we used to do on Daniel Woods back in the day. We're just like, dude, like move faster. Like, uh, but you know, he's one of those people who would just ISO everything, and I mean Aiden does it to even another level. I I don't know if that's like a knock on that's just I don't want to say even overpowered, but maybe overpowering is the right word. Like, what if he was quicker and more dynamic and selled into that position? Like, wouldn't that be better technique, like expending less effort to get the hold correctly?

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, I don't know. Maybe maybe he could learn to move a bit quicker. I mean, it would make sense on long boulders, wouldn't it? But yeah, he just it's hard to say. Um with people who are that good and that technical, it's really hard to see where the improvement could possibly be. And yet he's somehow magicking it up out of thin air.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, we had a a like almost like a joke clip where you can take some of these greats and try to take them down a notch where Sharma's feet are all over the place. Dave Graham seems like he could benefit from some more pull-ups. Uh, you know, maybe Daniel Woods or Aiden could move a little faster. And that's so obvious that we don't know what we're talking about because whatever they're doing, they have honed it to the absolute pinnacle of what they're doing, and that they're making the boulder and their style theirs. Like that's what is uniquely them, and it's kind of what sets them apart and makes them stand out. Where if you're kind of just like everyone else, almost by definition, you can't be the best. Like you can't be the best by doing what everyone else does. That unique

What Makes A Good Climber?

SPEAKER_01

special thing that makes them great is kind of what they're showcasing, rather than being like, hey, you need to keep your feet on more Sharma. It's like, really? You really want to tell Sharma how to climb? Like you think he isn't know what he's doing?

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, there aren't many pro-climbers that have obvious weaknesses, really, are they? I mean, like they're all pretty much phenomenal at this point. Um maybe Toby Roberts is someone who climbs slightly clumsily, um, which is just crazy to say for the Olympic gold medal winner that he's that good. Um, and I know some of the Brits like on the team used to say that Toby, they used to say of Toby when he was a bit younger, he's so unbelievably strong, he's never had to learn how to climb well. Because he's just so mind-blowingly strong. Um, and he just doesn't seem to get tired, you know, it's just ridiculous. But he's one of the only people I could say that sometimes you watch him climbing and you think that doesn't look particularly finessed. And yeah, there he goes.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, what could he do? Could he have won even more gold medals? Um, what do you think about this era that we're in? It kind of seems like that is the general critique of the crop of young people, whether it's Adam Shahar, uh Noah Wheeler, maybe Matt Mendez, um, sounds like Toby Roberts, where kind of the critique is, oh my God, you are so freaking strong. Let's see how you apply it. Like that that feels like the era we're in is just unbelievable potential in the young group. But that's kind of like a we'll wait and see if you are able to take that strength and potential and level up the sport.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, I mean, I guess that's kind of probably been the case for young people for a while. Because, you know, young people burn off old people on basic things, and then old people try and claw a little bit of honor and respect back by going, Yeah, we haven't actually done anything yet, so you know, scoreboard sort of thing. Um, but I think realistically it's just that's just the way it goes. You impress people inside for a while, doing incredible feats of strength, and then people say, Well, you haven't done it outside or whatever, and or in a competition, and then next thing you know, they have done it outside. Like it tends to be like first one then the other. So I was saying about Matt Mendez, like recently, you know, Lattice put forward a kind of list of everything he'd done on limestone in the season, and unfortunately, I think you got him on before he climbed his realm. Right before yeah, you got him on before, but actually, when you look at a guy who's so strong that he really impressed the likes of Noah Wheeler with his strength, actually that list of achievements was an underachievement for someone that good. It's like he the if you've got that kind of strength, then until you're kind of breaking new ground, it's all underachievement, which is this awful thing that we kind of set these young people up to be like, you can't just be impressive, you've got to be you know a savant, or it's or you've underachieved. And then maybe it makes it people in a box where it's almost like they never get to achieve because it's always less than the public perception.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, it's not a fun place to be in. If I I I said something to him about that, like what does it feel like just having everyone say that you've got 9A in the future, it's just a matter of time. I would feel like that's kind of heavy. It's it's like, yeah, of course you're gonna climb the hardest grade in the world. So go out there and just freaking do it like that. Because that's not how climbing works. And uh, you know, just because you're strong doesn't mean that you automatically get to do climbs. Like that's not that's not how the rock thinks. You know, you're just strong. That and and to me, that just shows potential. And I was just talking to my my editor, Adam, about this, where we always say this where it's like, wow, they have so much potential. Look at their strength, their ceiling is so high. Actually, it was a clip that just went out with Tom Randall of Lattice, where he basically said that Matt has a higher ceiling than Adam Andra does. And my kind of that's gonna get tons of clicks.

SPEAKER_00

I mean, steady on Tom. Steady on Tom. For some reason, Tom really has taken it on himself to like mega boost Matt's PR. I thought I've teased Matt a little bit because I've been calling him the boy with the PR because he's getting pushed so hard by Lattice. But that is a Laddis athlete. Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01

Well, um, my editor sure knew what to clip. Um, but but my kind of pushback on that is that, you know, so you got this potential with strength. Um, but just like I was saying, strength is no guarantee, it's just it's a requisite or a ceiling or a potential. And what we don't point out typically is oh, here's some young kid with unbelievably good mental fortitude for trying projects for a long time, or unbelievably bold uh and an ability to have confidence in their climbing uh while in risky situations. We don't usually point that out as potential when they're young, but the truth is to climb the hardest things in the world, there's a whole bunch of skills you need. You need strength, you need technique, maybe even need skin. You know, you need the ability to execute when the time is right. And so it's just kind of almost a misnomer to just look at strength and always be like, well, their ceiling is really high. It's true, but in the same breath, we should mention that you know Aiden's ceiling is really high, and he's unbelievably strong. But there's a lot of kids that come out that you hear about that are unbelievably strong, and they don't all become Aiden. And so there's more things going on than just potential strength.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, and I think also someone like Matt is never going to be able to be as well rounded as Aiden because Aiden's got a six-foot span and Mendez has got about a five foot four span. You know, he's Mendez is very short and he's got a negative ape index. So he's got a very short arm span, and that is going to rule him out just like you know, there's nothing he can do. It massively rules him out of a lot of boulders. Where someone like Aiden and Will don't have that problem because you know, Aiden's kind of obviously we joke all the time, he's genetically perfect. He's still quite short, so he's not wildly heavy, but he's got ridiculous wedge shoulders, which gives him this huge ape index. And like in climbing, you want to be somewhere around somewhere around five foot eight to five foot ten with six foot to six foot two armspan is about seems to be about perfect. Um, if you want to be able to kind of perform on everything. And for someone like Matt, it's like he's going to be outside of that to a degree that if he's gonna ever really wow us, he's probably gonna have to find a first ascent that's in his style and then show us what he can do, which is a lot. The reason why his ceiling isn't like Adam's is because I I do like to think of someone's climbing ability as is a little bit more than just what can they do in their style on something specific. It's Adam's incredible ability, his almost superhuman ability to do so much in so many different styles and to perform like the best. Like he turns up, he starts turning his hand at something, and he's suddenly the best at it. And that means like to say that someone like Matt has got a higher ceiling because Matt will be better on his exact style than on George, which I think is true. I don't think that's fair. I think you've got to kind of average things out across like a wider spectrum.

SPEAKER_01

First of all, thanks for saying that my build is perfect for climbing. I'm about five, nine, six foot wingspan. So I'm good. Me too. To be the same. All right. Um I I hear what you're saying where when we critique people as a climber, God's funny how we just have that word. Like, what does it mean to be good at climbing? And I would agree with you that one of the reasons why I put Andra on such a pedestal is because he's just good at everything. Like bold climbing, trad climbing, bouldering, flashing, rep. I mean, even comps, like, you know, if you were to want to take him down a notch on what his resume is lacking, it's literally just Olympic gold. Like that's like the only thing that you'd be like, oh, you know. Didn't get Olympic gold. But I would also point out that as our sport progresses to kind of like the ultimate levels of climbing ability, you're going to have to narrow into disciplines that showcase one's specialty. And that, you know, if we're talking about hard bouldering, you know, maybe that morphology of like the hardest problem in the world is going to be different than that kind of generic all-around size that you just, you know, kind of said it was a good, a good size to climb everything, where maybe you want to be unbelievably light and strong fingers, and that's what we then deem is like the hardest boulder in the world. Or you could go on the other end of the spectrum and it's like, you can only do this boulder if it's like a seven-foot wingspan. But that doesn't seem right either. And I don't know. It's it's something weird there.

SPEAKER_00

The only thing I would say is we've been saying that as like an aphorism now for like 10 plus years of like, you know, that the the future is going to be people hyper-specializing. But we haven't really seen it yet. Like most of the people who've climbed any of the hardest climbs or boulders go on to repeat other people's as well. No one has gone so far into something specific that it's like, this is this thing. And actually, it's one of the things I was talking to Tom Randall about. Because it's like, if you've you have become the best at this, like, you know, crack climbing right in front of your face, say, and you do something in that exact style, why are you giving it an easier grade, like you know, the hardest crack climb ever or whatever, and they're giving it like H C plus or something, or or whatever. You know, you've still reduced the grade, but actually what you've done is you have delved into a niche, but then you haven't capitalized on it in a sense, um, which is the wrong way of looking at it, but also you see what I mean. But like we haven't we haven't really seen that yet. But Matt is someone who I think could be a character to do that, and I would love to see someone who is maybe capable of climbing a 9A plus, or dare I say, even 9B, maybe. And I mean, I'm sure we'll see that in like 15 years or something, or 10 years, and and then not be able to repeat everyone else's, because it's like, no, I was that niche. The only person that springs to mind maybe Jane Svakova is is pushing quite hard into the like super limestone crimping game. And I think she will do Terra Nova, but maybe she's kind of focusing on that enough that she's not then going to go and repeat a bunch of other ones. I don't know. We'll have to say, I don't want to. Jane's lovely, so I don't want to kind of suggest that if that's not how she sees it. But maybe she's someone who's specializing quite hard. But most people seem to be a little bit broader.

SPEAKER_01

That's interesting because kind of a corollary there is there's an assumption then that if you are good at climbing, period, even if you specialize at something, somehow that seems to end up being transferable. So even if you're at a mandora and you know he spent a lot of time on-siding sport routes for a long, long time. And you know, it seems like when he applies himself to crack climbing, he gets really good at really quick. And I would I would guess that if he wanted to go do Drifter's Escape, that you know, new 15A and squamish that's on gear, I think he could do it. I don't I don't think anyone would would disagree. Just like he did Donwall quite quickly and easily. And so does that mean that there's something inherent about climbing fundamentally, especially on, I think the caveat here would be on rock, not on uh plastic where we could probably take things to an ultimate zenith around a specific style that like somehow it if you're good at one thing on rock, given time and effort, you probably somehow are good at rock climbing, period.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, I think at the moment, getting really, really good at one style, you can then bully a lot of the other climbs into that style. And I think that's why climbing is still quite interesting to talk about because we keep kind of we think we see where the future's going and then being wrong, which is quite fun. It means you know, there's so much more to talk about when we're wrong. If every prediction we made was right, it would get a bit like, oh, well, I'll just repeat myself, shall I? Every, you know, every year I'll say, Yeah, this is still happening, just like I said it did two years ago. Uh and I think the way climbing's developing, like, you know, again, something that's really surprised me, I thought was amazing, was um Diane Aktar doing Return of the Sleepwalker so fast, as a guy who's basically never climbed on rock. Sleepwalker was his first eighth grade boulder, and then a couple of days later, his first ninth grade boulder was returned. Like he really hasn't climbed on rock. He is just a comp climber, and it is transferable. And I think maybe we've been a bit, you know, guilty of saying, oh, these comp climbers, they're not, they can't do it on rock to the you know top level. Maybe they can, you know, they're just they're just not doing it because they're busy, but the moment they are doing it, maybe they can.

SPEAKER_01

I talked about this with Joe Plachy and this idea that in general, if you're a comp climber, the goal is to kind of raise all of your skill levels because you never know what you're going to encounter at a at a comp. You know, it's just kind of luck of the draw in some ways. And sometimes, you know, like those poor people who had to do a crack boulder, remember at some World Cup, and no one could do probably like the unbelievably easy hand jam and Almondra just crushed it because he had crack climb. So in general, like you have no idea what to expect. So they're trying to raise all levels. But then in outdoor climbing, the challenge of the boulder in front of you at a high level is very specific. It's like very specific. And it's just this interesting thing where if you take people and they spend their whole climbing life getting good at everything because they never know what to expect, when they go outdoors, sure enough, they're able to accomplish quite a bit in a short time. Uh so the only caveat I want to point out there is I don't know if you've been to Red Rocks, but that kind of sandstone climbing is very gym-like.

SPEAKER_00

It's very that's what that's actually what Aiden said. Aiden said that um if it sandstone would be the rock type that you reckoned the comp climbers would do best at. I'm just kind of cautious about I don't want to become like a kind of unk saying, like, you know, oh these these young guys they can't do what what the other guys are doing on the rock. Because I think also when you look at the pure rock climbers, they're mostly ex-comp climbers and in some cases failed comp climbers. You know, like they they couldn't cut it, they couldn't cut it as a comp climber, they weren't the best comp climber, and they've now got into rock climbing. But so really, the when the first sentence in your curriculum V tie is I wasn't the best, definitively, maybe we shouldn't assume that these people are then the best when they get on rock. Maybe they are, but maybe they're not. And you know, I'm very grateful really that the comps have hoovered up so many of the um youngsters because it's kept someone like me vaguely relevant for a lot longer than I deserved. You know, I'm still hanging in there, I'm a couple of grades back, but I'm doing stuff that's you know, it's considered hard. If all of the young people were climbing on rock as well, I mean, I wouldn't get a look in.

SPEAKER_01

That is

The Problem With “No Matching” Boulders

SPEAKER_01

a freaking hilarious point to make that a lot of the best outdoor climbers are ones that failed at the comp scene, saw some success outdoors, and then lean into it. But you're basically saying maybe that is not because outdoor climbing and comp climbing are so different, it's just because those people failed at comp climbing, so that's what they had to go to. So that is brutal. That's brutal.

SPEAKER_00

They're there, and the people who are really good at comp climbing are still comp climbing. But obviously, you know, there are exceptions to the rule. We got the likes of Jacob, who's another, you know. I think Jacob is right up there with Andra. I don't think that there's much of a gap there. And I think maybe Jacob is the only person who's within spitting distance of Andra. But besides those two, there mostly are people who've kind of stepped away from the comps at the very top. Um, and in some ways you can see it, like you know, someone like Aiden has a super strength, which wasn't coming up in comps. So it was never going to be a great comp climber because he's he they basically was like taking his super strength away. Kind of like um okay, should we talk? This is this is actually a board-related thing to mention. Oh yeah, board pack. Oh, welcome to board pack. We've got a lot of very disappointed board advocates listening so far. But um, how do you feel about the um no matching rules on that's so prevalent on tension boards?

SPEAKER_01

Uh I don't like the no-matching rules. I I can come around to this. Uh, you know, I've I've talked to Michael Rosotto, who you know well, who you did a board talk with on Careless Talk. A Careless Board Talk.

SPEAKER_00

It was definitely a careless board talk. It was very bold heavy, wasn't it?

SPEAKER_01

Uh before I steal man what Michael would say, I'll just share my my kind of two cents on it. I don't like having rules in climbing, and I think it's because of lazy setting often. Like it's it's like I I want to climb how I climb. I want to be free to think outside the box, to put my left hand where people thought the right hand went to, you know, like use something as a foot that no one thought was going to be a foot to match, do something heinous uh that you know I make it work because that's how I figured out the problem. Like that's not it shouldn't be cheating to be clever. Like that's how you push your ability and your and and how you unlock sequences outside where there are no rules. I just I hate having rules. Like I came, I already mentioned I came from gymnastics. I remember starting to compete in climbing, and there was no right or wrong way. I it was just like get to the top, Josh. Good luck. And I just did crazy stuff because also back then there wasn't as much kids stuff, and I would compete in comps with adults, and it was hilarious because I couldn't reach holds or feet, and I had to do really wild things. And I just love that freedom to unlock something creatively, and so when you tell me like no matching, I'm like, dude, let me climb how I want to climb.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, yeah, I mean, I I sort of do agree. I think like there are times when I love it, and I'm like, yes, this you've created a super cool sequence that if you allowed matching, just wouldn't work because these holds are matchable, and I think it's really cool, but I think it's unfortunate that it's become the default, and like 95% plus of boulders seem to be no matching. And the reason why I bring it up now is because I I have some sympathy for people where for some people matching is their super strength. The thing that they're so good at is being able to match. And I am not one of those people, I've got fat, really fat fingers, and I suck at matching. And then, you know, I put up a boulder on um uh the Moon Board 24, and uh Sierra Blair climbed it by matching every hold. And I think that's really cool, but she wouldn't be able to do that on the tension board because it would have had no matching on it. And I could, you know, sit there and criticize her for breaking my boulder. I can't do that. You know, I I can't do what she had just done. So if she'd found a way to say, like, you know, matching only, then I wouldn't be able to do the boulder because of a button that she's clicked, which is exactly what we're doing when we set on the TV too. If we click that button, we're sort of taking people who they can do it with their incredible matching skill, and we're saying, ah, but you can't now, because I click this toggle, you're screwed.

SPEAKER_01

I really love that that idea of for like forcing people not to match, would be like forcing people to match. Like she that would be a hilarious boulder to set.

SPEAKER_00

Uh but isn't it funny that we think that we immediately know that that sounds ridiculous? Because like no matching is like a thing that we accept in climbing. We think that's normal. But if there was another toggle that says you have to match every hole, we'd be like, that's that's crazy.

SPEAKER_01

I mean, I just think it boils down to a discussion we've had before, and I think we're not totally aligned where it's like, are boards training, or are they something else when there's a leaderboard? Like, you know, are they an end unto themselves or are they just training? And when you start coming up with arbitrary rules, to me, you know, you can take it one of two ways. You can say like, no matching because I'm trying to train this move, you know, I'm trying to really make sure you lock off this hold. Or you could say, I'm doing no matching because uh, you know, we're trying to make it a certain grade or you know, make it fair for everyone to have to do that big move. And so to me, it's like this different way you look at boards. Are you just saying that we're just training and so we create arbitrary rules in order to enforce a specific type of movement, or are we trying to enforce a specific type of difficulty because we're competing against one another? And you know, I think that that's part of the discussion there about forcing movement. Like, why are you forcing it? And yeah, I I just I think that's relevant here.

SPEAKER_00

I I yeah, I think I may be slightly falling into the trap of getting offended on behalf of someone else because this doesn't bother me really at all, because I can't match things anyway. So it doesn't, I can't think of a single time where this has actually bothered me because I I'm rubbish at matching. But I just have this nagging feeling in my head that if there was a toggle that said forced matching and that was the reason I couldn't do it, that would be major feels bad. I would be having no fun, and I'd be very annoyed at the system for taking my way of climbing away from me. I mean, matching just sucks. Let's just let's just call it what it is. No one likes to match. I think you would get a torrent of toxic masculinity on this podcast, God. I don't know.

SPEAKER_01

I don't know if that's I feel like there's some other podcast that supposedly is associated with that. Um I did this climb in Waco that was called French Tickler. By the way, if you ever do go Waco, I think it's one of the best V9s. Oh yeah, and also just super fun. Um, but it's called the French Tickler because you're supposed to match. And I was like, no, I will not match. And so I literally did the problem entirely different just to avoid the matching and even ruin its namesake. And I think this is what is fun about climbing, about how climbing progresses, is that like if you enforce these rules, then you don't get to explore new ways of doing climbs, right? Like I didn't match. It was called the French tickler literally because of that. And if you had forced me to do that, it would have made me miserable and it would have would have ruined my experience on there. And so that's why fundamentally I'm just against arbitrary rules because I feel like it makes climbing less fun. Like what I like about climbing is that I can somehow like, and that's where I wanted to push back about you're saying Matt Mendez has a shorter wingspan. And so by default, that means that he is maybe limited in the boulders that he can do in the world. And I'm not a hundred percent sure on that. Like the best in the world take what they have and beat it into their style, like you were saying, and and a good example is uh Beckett Shinn, who's uh I think he's 5'2 or or so, or maybe 5'4. He's he's quite short. Um, I don't know if you know who he is. He's a young guy out here. Um, he just did Vanilla Sky, which is notorious for being a reachy boulder and perhaps impossible, uh, at like under a 6'2 span, and he figured it out at you know, a foot shorter. Um, and so you know, again, like I just don't like being for don't tell me how to climb, damn it. Like, let me do my thing. That's what I like about climbing.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, and I I agree. I I agree wholeheartedly, and I think that but we do have a kind of protective nature when we set boulders that we for some reason we want people to do it the way we intended. And I think that's why it's so easy to click the, you know, oh just no matching. And you know, Ben hates it. Ben has never let us have a no-matching toggle. Maybe it's because the app is straining at the seams, but um he he says we you know he doesn't like it and we can't have one. Um, and sometimes it's a real shame because it's like it would open up so much possibility. But I just wonder how we could have it without it becoming the default? How could we have it, but you can't do it every time? It's like almost like you should be allowed to do it on one of every like five boulders you set or something.

SPEAKER_01

I mean, it's just it comes down to the shaping. It's it's making holds that are not shaped to allow for magic. Like, you know, if you're gonna put a big ledge on, although gosh, I have seen people match things on the moon board that are just there's like I I couldn't even fathom. Like, I think um, God, what's her name? Uh like Julia Boback. There, there's this woman who was on the 2019 set when I was spending a lot of time on it. And you know, back then, maybe I don't

New Info On The MoonSpray

SPEAKER_01

know, maybe six years ago, there just wasn't that many people on boards, and so you kind of knew them all on Instagram, is how I met you. Um, and I think she matched that heinous wooden pinch, like you know, that weird knob pinch that uh has like the rounded yes uh top. I I don't remember where, but I want to say she like matched that. And it was just insane to me.

SPEAKER_00

Like I said, no space to match it for me. No way, no way would I be able to do that. Also, not only that, but you'd have to be so strong in midline, you know, you'd have to you've both your hands would be right in front of your solar plexus. So, you know, to have to be able to hold that position, but also to move out of that position would be horrendous. So, yeah, I've I just haven't got that in me.

SPEAKER_01

That's actually why I don't think I like matching, is I need the the I need a little compression. I always like when you start putting my hands right next to each other, I feel like I lose a lot of my ability. Is yeah, you know, just being close uh to my midline, I really struggle. I don't like it. Um I really do want to hear about the moon spray. Just you you've you somehow, maybe just in your excellent podcaster ability, you saw the outline uh and you steered us toward the moon spray, which I want to know literally as much about as possible.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, I mean, I don't the so so basically I've only had one proper session on it, which was videoed, and it's with uh Aidan and Katie. And by the time this comes out, it will be available on the moon YouTube. So I'll shout that out. Go and go and watch that. But something that really shocked me was how easy it was to set very, very hard boulders on it. It has got a lot of really bad holds, like really bad holds. And even though this is not the set that I did, my set was thrown in the bin and Ben reset it. And yet, even though I'm not responsible for this, he's put a lot of the bad holds on the steep side where I had them more in the middle or on the left, which is the less steep side. So now that there is some, you know, there's a video in there of Aidan and Katie working on this um 8B they put up on the right hand side, and the moves are tiny, like sort of foot, they're like sort of 10 inches or a foot little stab moves between these holes, and he's got a huge heel hook in, and the holes are that bad that that's what you need to do to get up it. So I think I say in the video, and I think I stand by this, that I think it is gonna be a case that the easiest climbs on a moon board are gonna be on the spray, and the hardest climbs on a moon board are gonna be on the spray. Awesome. I it does have some proper sinking jugs on it. Um more so than I would have put on, to be honest. I would have had fewer sinking jugs, but there are plenty of sinking jugs on there. Um, but there are some holes that are so bad that I think you know, a lot of people would have said, oh, we shouldn't put this on because it's so bad. But it's usable, but it's gonna be hard to use.

SPEAKER_01

Good to hear. I I think that you had talked about putting the worse holds on the less steep section and the better holds on the steeper section to kind of round out, I guess, the difficulty. I I want to say that we talked about that. Um, so that's interesting that he went the other end of the spectrum. And literally one of the Patreon questions for you was like, will there be actually hard boulders on the moon spray? Like, are we going to see the hardest boulders? And hearing that there's also like a tikky tacky, like that's the opposite of what I think about when I think about hard boulders on moon boards, are like big, giant moves on relatively good holes. And so that's a big departure.

SPEAKER_00

Yes. Yeah. It is a big departure. It doesn't feel traditional moon board climbing at all. It really does feel different. You know, they're calling it the moon spray. It really doesn't feel like a moon board.

SPEAKER_01

Dude, what is this? Okay. We have moon boards. We have moon spray. And you just said like it doesn't feel like a moon board. It feels like a moon spray. Like, what is the difference? Like, we have these flat walls that are boards. It's like this is a spray wall. Like, clearly, like, you know, a moon board is a spray wall. Like, like, how could it not be? And then we have like something that now has angles and some macros. It's a spray. Like, I just, I like, don't think they're different. I guess deep down inside, I don't think they're any different.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah. And I think Michael said something similar where it's like, well, we we consider the tension board a spray. I mean, it's literally called the tension spray setup. Um, and it's a spray of holds across a board. So I think they're reasonable in in in saying that they think it's a spray. But I think for us, the way we were imagining the difference, which is made up and arbitrary, but the way we were imagining the difference was that the more three-dimensional you make it, so with more volumes and big holds, like big holds, like proper big holes mingling with little ones, the way those things work together makes it into a spray. That kind of like texture in in the in the difference makes it makes the difference. But so there are these huge, great fiberglass holds, there are these volumes. And I think Ben had this real vision. This is what he wanted. He wanted something to be much more three-dimensional, to give people opportunity to climb on big holds, and that's why I think we parted ways in the way we set it, because what I was essentially doing was sorting all the board climbers out, and I basically had the right-hand side perfect for board climbing, and that's not what he wanted. So I was taking the volumes off and being like, we don't need that, we don't need that, throw that away. That one's too big. I don't like how much space that hold takes up. And I was making a kind of something more conventional board climb situation, and I think Ben had to kind of come back in and say, Yeah, this is not what I wanted, you've not really got it. We're gonna do it again, and we're gonna make it this like really three-dimensional thing. And that has not made the climbing easier by any means, but it has made it different, and it has made it much more different than current boards. Like, there's nothing else like it currently. It's nothing like, you know, I know Michael says that the attention board they say is a spray, but it's it's a completely different thing now. Like it doesn't climb like that.

SPEAKER_01

I'm all for this expansion of boards, both in uh yeah, or when I say boards, I'm gonna say kind of like standardized boards to to put a little bit of a more category on it versus just a spray. Like these, like I can buy a moon spray, you know, I I can have one over here. So, yeah, that that's that is a big difference from what just a classic spray wall is. So I'm all about seeing this exploration into bigger holds, angle change. And let's be clear, that thing is big. Like, that's probably not going in in a garage. That's probably going in a gym. Uh and I guess the the one thing that's just strange to me is although I'm all for that, I was thinking about like the size of this and just kind of the general trend or trajectory we're on. And then somehow I had this flashback to uh Magnus uh video where he like had a new gym and it had holds all over and they were clear, and then you could change the color. And yeah, like the whole gym was like almost like a LED type of gym that had a spray set up to it. And I'm so against that. Like I don't want that. That seems dystopian, yet I'm totally for what you know the moon spray is. And like I see this trajectory where we're on, but then somehow when I see almost like the ultimate version of it where a gym is just littered with holes that then you can, you know, LED your way through. I don't like that. Like, where's that line where that is no fun, but it's fun what you guys just built or what Ben just built.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, I honestly I have no idea. I don't know. I think it's for me when I see the um have you seen the uh like the Japanese gyms? There's like a few Japanese gyms where like every bit of wall is a hole. And it's Volney, I want to say like volny or something like that. V something. Yeah, yeah. It's insane. And people people send it to me and they're like, this is the most like this is the coolest thing I've ever seen. I'm like, isn't it? It looks like the same hold dives a billion. Like it's like if I was gonna do this, I might have used slightly different holds. Like it looks like um A, it looks like it's gonna give me a seizure, but B, it's a seizure. It's like they're they're all like it looks like you've bought 200 of the same jib and just put them all next to each other. But anyway, that's by the way. Um yeah, I don't know. I think it's it's going to be so different that I'm really fascinated to see how the uptake is going to be. And I think we're now moving into a new era of boards, of commercial boards, where the product is now less than 50% of the problem, in the sense that you could make an amazing board, but what makes an amazing commercial board is that they exist and that they're out there and that there's a big bank of problems. So if you have the best board the world's ever seen, but there's two of them, that's less good as a commercial offering than a 2016 moon board, which actually, as a board, I don't think is that amazing, but there's thousands of them. So you could have a 2016 board in your house like Ravioli, have a 2016 board in your house and never get bored. I mean, he's gone back to the 2016 set. You think wild. You think like surely this is enough, you know, you got you got to move on. But he's back, he loves it, and he's still creating new boulders, and you know, no one can complete it. There's just thousands and thousands of boulders. So so now I think it's quite funny because now it's like product, but yes, but I think that's now gonna become the minor problem, and now the big problem is gonna be marketing and PR and pushing it. And I'm quite fascinated to see climbing companies who are traditionally terrible at that, yeah, for that to become the problem. And that, you know, tension is so good at it, and that's one of the things we want to talk to Michael about. He is brilliant at board PR in a way that no one else is at the minute.

SPEAKER_01

I talked to Michael years ago, and it was kind of I I think the TB2 had just come out, maybe, and he told me about the work he was doing on writing articles at the time. I don't remember where they were in their YouTube journey, but he he made some comment. I I may be misremembering this, but it was my takeaway that they wanted to kind of be thought leaders in the space. Yeah, they wanted to show that they really know boards, care about boards, and they put out a lot of effort into sharing their knowledge with the world. And not so much just like, we're the best, you know, but just about boards themselves, just learning about boards, growing the culture and the community, and not necessarily just saying like we have the best board, but just educating the whole world about boards. And so I I think they've gone down that route really successfully, and it was a lot of effort that they put in and they they had a very clear vision. And and honestly, when I heard it at the time, I just I didn't think too much of it. I was like, good luck with that. Like only a couple weirdos like boards like me and maybe Sam. Uh, and then like now it's you know, they've really it's really paid off, and they really have done a good job, and they're not taking their foot off the gas, it doesn't look like, you know, there's just great content being put out by them.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, I'm interested to hear your take on it, but do you think the thing that makes the tension board too good is the tension board to itself or board lords and the PR behind it?

SPEAKER_01

Well, you're going, I'm gonna go back to what you were saying. That's interesting. You you basically pointed out something along the lines of network effects, uh, where if you have the best board, but there's only two of them, like is it really the best board? And it's kind of this classic example of the fax machine is a good example of network effects. So the fax machine, when it comes out, is I could fax you something. That sounds crazy in today's world because we like email, but you're almost old enough to remember fax machines.

SPEAKER_00

Oh, we had a fax machine. We had a fax machine.

SPEAKER_01

So fax machines aren't very valuable when there's one of them. They become a lot more valuable when there's two of them. And basically every new fax machine that goes into the world and is accessible actually increases the value of every fax machine in the world. It's a you know, it's a fast, it's kind of like Facebook was like this too. Like, you know, that's like the classic network effect idea. And so I don't even know if it's worth worrying about is the actual base product the best. I I think each board has pros and cons, but starts becoming who has it? Do your friends have it? Because if my friends are climbing on whatever board, like that makes it more valuable to me. And if yeah, if and if they put out a board lords and those climbs are really good, then we can talk about those climbs and do those climbs. I think that makes them more valuable sheerly. Like the marketing does add value, actually. Like it's not just a trick, it's not just like a a ploy. It literally makes it more fun to participate in that activity on that thing. Whether we're talking about tension or moon or kilter, like I I'm not trying to be too narrow and critiquing any of them, but I think that I wouldn't denigrate the marketing and say it's just a trick. I think actually that literally adds value and makes it more fun. So it it increases the value of the product.

SPEAKER_00

Exactly. And it's an interesting you know case where this is. But what I would do if I owned one of these companies, if you know, say, say I was Ben Moon.

SPEAKER_01

The careless board? No, dude, you guys could do it.

SPEAKER_00

You and Amy, I would, I would buy that board. We could, we could, we could do it. And you know, maybe, maybe one day we'll be I'll be back on here and I'll be talking about the board we're bringing out. But say, okay, say let's let's put myself back in my own shoes, my least favorite place to be. Um let's let's imagine we've made the careless, the careless talk board. I would be looking to shift the first 20, 30, 40 units at a loss. I would be like, I'm gonna save up some money and I'm gonna, you know, obviously people need to pay, people need to pay something to offset my crippling damages. You know, I've just remortgaged my house for this. But I would be looking to try and get rid of as many as I could, while I could still stomach it, because you need to get them out there. And every one of those, they're making your product. You know, when someone buys one of these new boards, you know, it's no longer the case for the moon board, the kilt to the tension. There's plenty of them. You know, they've they've they've they've done this. But if you've created a new board and you haven't done this, for every person who buys it, as you were saying with the fax machine, it makes the product more desirable. And then so later I'll jack up the price for the Johnny Come Latelies. I'll be like, yeah, you didn't you didn't like it at first. Well, now you want it, don't you? Because I've got my board lords going and you're desperate to go climb, you know, Zach Galler's, you know, whatever the uh Abercrombie and Fitch boys have been smashing out over at Tension Board at HQ. You know, you want a bit of that action, don't we all?

SPEAKER_01

Um Abercrombie and Fitch Boys, Zach, please comment about being called the Abercrombie and Finch Boy.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, I'm showing my age, showing my age a bit now. I'm not sure Abercrombie and Finch has got the same vibe as it did when I was younger. I think maybe I might be uh might be dadding out a little bit there. But um that's those are that's I'm unking. Yeah, you're unky. See, I'm fighting it, but it's a it's a I I can't resist. It's gonna catch me anyway. I can I can run, but I can't hide from the unktakes. It happens to the best of us. Yeah. I guess physically being an uncle, you're gonna come out with some unkes. You can't avoid it.

SPEAKER_02

Yeah.

SPEAKER_00

All right, hold on.

SPEAKER_01

I've lost, I got lost while laughing about thinking about Zach being an Abercrombie and Fitch guy. Uh they do all have a similar haircut though, right? Like Zach, Sean Rabatou. They all do have a similar, they're all a bunch of Abercrombie and Fitch models. Drew Ron had that haircut as well.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah. The 90s, the 90s center parting is back. And actually, talking about being a dad and things coming back, quite a lot of the music I actually like is coming back. People are putting the youngsters are putting music on their Instagram reels that I actually like. And I've got to keep very quiet about that because if I say that, I mean I've said this on the podcast, like but Nirvana, Sublime, what is this what we're talking about? Stuff that I thought was cool when I was at school is now kind of creeping back in. And if I let this out you know too much, then I'm gonna put put them off, and they'll be back with the music and everything.

SPEAKER_01

You're saying being in yeah, being an unk is a good thing. Actually, I gotta tell you behind the scenes on good temps that cracked me up. So we will get comments about being unk, like unk vibes for real or something like that. You've got three unks, you've got three unks on, yeah. So so uh Carlo, who probably has the most unk vibes, we told him, or we like copied that comment and put it in the group chat. And Carlo thought being an unk was cool, like you know, like your cool uncle. I was like, that's the most unk thing you could ever have said right there.

SPEAKER_00

That's just Teflon. You know, you just can't nothing sticks to him. You can't touch Carlo. Takes as a compliment. Too good.

SPEAKER_01

Uh all right. I completely forgot about what boards we're talking about we're talking about network effects. Is it good? Oh, oh, I know. So what you're telling me is that you could get me a moon spray for very cheap. You're gonna give me a moon spray because I'm doing Ben a favor. Is that what's gonna happen?

SPEAKER_00

That if see if I was Ben, that would be the case. I do not believe that is the case. I think I spoke to I did mention this to Ben. I don't think he he liked it um at all. Maybe he feels like he spent enough money that throwing more money uh at the wall might not be a good idea.

SPEAKER_01

Well, it was easy for you to give away his money, it was very easy for you to, but he thought maybe perhaps he didn't want to give away his money. Yeah, exactly.

SPEAKER_00

Yes, yeah. I think you know he's spent a and he has done something that not many people would do. You know, he's spent an awful lot of money developing this product, which nobody is telling him this is a gold mine. You know, you know, he knows this is a risk, he knows like he might struggle to shift units. And I think it's really cool that he's willing to take that risk and make something so different, which is really good. And I'm gonna be um moving to Sheffield in a couple of months, and I'm gonna be when I'm up there, I'm gonna be spending a lot of time on that board. You're moving. Yes, I'm moving, I'm moving to Sheffield. Okay, that's the epicenter. Yeah, the tractor beam of British climbing is is finally hauling me in. Um yeah, but and and and then I'll I'll know more. But yeah, I I I think that's the sort of outside of climbing business strategy we haven't really seen yet, and in the sense like marketing and PR was once almost outside of the climbing scene and now is coming in. But there are elements that like this is just this is good business sense.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah. Quick

Support From Patreon

SPEAKER_01

break while I tell you about today's sponsor. Thank you to all the patrons who helped make this show possible. Join them so you can get episodes early before anyone else. And those episodes are ad-free. As a patron, you also get to submit questions for upcoming guests. The answers to those questions are only available to patrons. Follow the link in the show notes to join now. You also get access to a private Discord where you'll find me and other people who want to go from good to great. Okay, back to the pod. I I really wish I was at the Vertical Pro event. I don't know what you call it, uh, trade show. I think it's a trade show. Vertical Pro is like an indoor climbing trade show that's happening. It'll be done by the time this comes out next week, I think. It's this weekend, isn't it? Free show. November 10th, just to let everyone know. It's my mom's birthday too. So happy birthday.

SPEAKER_00

Oh, happy birthday to Josh's mouth.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, yeah. Uh, and I kind of wish I was going to that. I I want to see that you know, there's gonna be boards there. There's lots of people. I know the moon spray is launching there. I mean, that's what the Instagram, that's what Instagram told me, is that that's where Ben is officially going and hopefully, you know, selling units. And I got handed to him for building something that is not just the 2026 moon board. I like you know, like you were saying, there's a lot of value in the board being in the world, having that network effect, having thousands of problems, having videos of Sam and Aiden and Katie on it. Like that, that provides a lot of value. And so what I am not sightseeing is just a little touch different, new derivative product that's not new and different. Like the people who are willing to take a risk, like Ben is, I there's no guarantee of success, but as a climber, as a someone who is a board lover and connoisseur, I can't say all love it because I haven't gotten to climb on it yet. But I'm so excited to try something that is different and new. I want something different and new. So props to him for taking that risk. And, you know, and I hope it works out for him.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah. And I also I would say I couldn't guarantee that you would love the product. That's you know, subjective, but I could absolutely guarantee that you would love some of the boulders that will be on the product. Yeah. You know, because they're really they're gonna be different, they're gonna be cool, there's gonna be a lot of variety. And I think everybody, all climbers will have some great sessions on the moon spray. And you can't really say that about every board. 2016 is so brutal, dude. No, yeah, exactly. You know, if you don't climb sort of V5 and up, you're not even gonna get up to the top of it, and then you're gonna have no fun. So you know, so it is cool that this is something you could share a session with with someone in rentals.

SPEAKER_01

So, what is new about the moon spray that uh maybe we don't know about yet? Like, is the it looks like maybe the lighting system is the middle of the holds. Uh is the kickboard always on? Is the app the same? Like, is there anything that is fundamentally different about the moon spray other than kind of like the shape of the of the spray, you know, and and the bigger holds?

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, so I mean it doesn't have a kickboard, uh, which is different. Um, it does have a kind of so it's a higher density than any moon board. Um, which I think is something that will probably look to happen to all moon boards in the future, is increasing the density because density is good. Um I think you know, actually having big fiberglass on it as well is is new. Also, it's covered in PE, it's polyester, which means it will last forever. And they've done the same logic they've applied to the fiberglass. When it's new, it is gonna shred your skin, but then it will bed in and last forever. Whereas if you go with the low texture, once it's bedded in, it's it's become you know very hard to use. So I think besides besides that, and the volumes all came back on, despite my protestations, they're all back. Um, and they're well set, you know, there's there's appropriate holds for the volumes. And I think it really is like a spray in the sense that it is gonna be covered in conventional indoor bouldering boulders. You know, there's gonna be like really techie things. You could so you can do some dinos on it if if that's your game, you know, there'll be double clutches and stuff perfectly settable. They're not gonna be coming from me, but someone will be setting them. Um, you know, that's all possible. And that's the sort of stuff that you don't really get on boards, like the the kind of like that kind of dynamic modern movement, I suppose, is still pretty rare.

SPEAKER_01

So you mentioned that yeah, the the earlier setup ended up getting redone, which is probably pretty standard. Like uh it'd almost worry me if they had just put up holds, and that was like you know, the first go was the best go. I I remember seeing a video of the quantum board being set by Stefano. Um, you know, this was like years ago, and it just worried me watching them put holds on. It was like you give a bunch of pro climbers like a drill and just say, hey, set our spray wall. It's like, no, this takes a lot more care and effort than that. And I don't know if they had other iterations, but iterations aren't a bad thing. So I wouldn't be too hard on you for the first one not going well. And I had seen some pictures, either I can't remember where, I saw some pictures of maybe the first layout, and the colors were bad, man. There was like they changed, they changed.

SPEAKER_00

Don't do do not panic. The colors have have changed. Yes, the colors were were bad at first. It was um it was bad. It was lurid. Yeah, it was lurid. Yeah. The only reason for how there I'm full of them. The uh uh the um the kind of the only use case for how. Having a wall look like that is when you don't have lights, isn't it? Because then you've got enough variety in colour that you can remember where you're going. Um with lights, it made no sense. So there are like that orange is gone, that green is gone. Is the yellow gone? No, maybe the yellow is still there. But certainly a lot of the colours have gone, and now it looks a lot less sort of uh dizzying to the eye.

SPEAKER_01

Dude, I I was really happy to see the color scheme now. Uh, because this matters, like aesthetics matter. And the previous that, yeah, those purples and greens didn't look great. It's it's interesting now how the boards I again. I'm just gonna come back to kind of we have a big three, we have moon and tension and kilter. And you know, you get this kind of colorful uh uh you know array of uh holds on the moon spray now. Uh you know, tension's a little more, I don't know, kind of like dungeon-y. It's got that like the blacks, the grays, the wood, you know, it's got that kind of vibe. And then kilter has this kind of monochromatic feel. And like it's interesting that everyone's kind of choosing their lane, you know, and and making sure that they stand out visually, which I like. And yeah, I just thought it looks a lot better, man. Good, good job, Ben, taking down sales uh set and coloring it. Yes, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_00

That that's that was definitely a good move. I think the way it's being set is gonna be really cool. The the um silhouette model of setting was gonna be really cool when it comes to actually setting it. So, you know, how the panels so the panels are gonna have the silhouette of the holds on and the number. So, God, that's gonna be nice. You can just pick up a hold, see the number, smash it on, have it absolutely perfect without having, you know, I was setting a TB2 again the other day, and like, oh god, north northeast. Oh, is that is that right? And then you think, oh, I think that's a bit wrong, actually. And like the difference it makes getting it slightly off is is painful. Um, and uh yeah, so I think that's gonna make setting it so much nicer, and the uniformity of it is gonna be so much better, which I think is really cool.

SPEAKER_01

How important do you think uniformity is between boards? And you know, how how important is it that everyone's fax machine spits out the same thing?

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, I think that is one of the sort of dark truths of these standardized boards in that they're actually not the same. You know, um I know the moon yellow holds are terrible for it, massively different sizes. Uh that's one of the reasons I moved away from them. But you know, I noticed a couple of my tension board button crimp holds were very different sizes as well. So it just is so hard. You know, you just can't really get it right unless it's getting all machine made. You kind of can't get it perfectly right. Um so there is, I think you always have to take it with a grain of salt, and you can't standardize conditions, and we all know how much conditions make a difference. So I think you have to not worry too much unless someone's done something in front of you on the same board on the same day. It's not exactly the same. And then they had really greasy mitts, so they've just left their greasy, sweaty hands all over the hole. So you know you're sort of never climbing the same thing, so you're just doing your best, aren't you?

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, and you need to have something to to blame. You gotta have something. Yeah, exactly. Like give me something to let the world know why I didn't send uh and I I I've kind of talked about this before, where I'm both obsessed with the uniformity and standardization, and then totally okay with it being different. And I think that or when I say different, I mean like it doesn't have to be perfect because I think all this stuff is fun. Where if you find out someone climbs some outdoor boulder in the middle of summer, it's impressive because you're like, dude, this was in the sun, it was hot, and you sent this crimpy problem or this slopey problem. Like, how did you do that? Like it makes it more interesting. And so I think boards become notoriously slick or bad, and then when you see someone send something on that, that's exciting. But then it always should still filter into some kind of board lords or a competition or something that on the day at the place where you and your buddies are climbing, you know. And so I don't think it's bad that there's like a little variation. I think it kind of adds some reality, but also some kind of fun where it's like, wow, you sent it on that board. Like everyone knows that board's hard. I I think that adds to lore versus the idea of like making it all perfect in the same is just it's a fool's uh errand, too, because it will never actually happen.

SPEAKER_00

It will never happen. So it's yeah, it's I think it's something that people just have to accept. Um but that's not to say that when you realize you've got a horrendous shallow pour of a hold, that is gonna feel bad. Like that sucks. I don't, you know, that that's also unavoidable. So we all we all feel a bit hard done by when we realize that that's happened to us.

SPEAKER_01

But I'll never forget stumbling upon the idea of shallow pores and then realizing that mine was super shallow poured, my my yellow holds, and my buddy just given me such a hard time. He's like, You're weak, you suck, stop trying to blame things. And I took it off. I drove two hours and showed him like and compared them. I was like, Look, look, my hold sucks. Like uh, and just the look on his face was priceless. I'll never forget. So um, maybe I'm just grateful for for that one that one day. You could have stumbled into an intervention there, Josh, if you I I want all boards to come with this outline, or at the very least, I I want to say that there's boards that they have like etched notches in them. So like if you buy tension holds, you line them up with like a line that's like north or something. Like isn't there something going on like that?

SPEAKER_00

Yes, yes. Oh gosh, I want to say who it was because I saw them at one of the things and they were really nice. Um, but there is a new there's a new angle changing board where the boards come with it, and on the boards is etched in the hold number of whatever you're making, the hold number and a little compass thing to get it right. Oh god, that'd be so nice to set. Um uh and unfortunately, despite they were so nice, and I was uh I've I've unfortunately forgotten the name of the company. I'd love to give them a shout-out, but I've forgotten. Offset, offset, offset, offset offset.

SPEAKER_01

Okay, okay. Um, so does this mean that there won't be a different moon spray layout? Like, does this link limit them to that layout?

SPEAKER_00

Essentially, yes. This was the payoff. This is the payoff that's risky. That we were yes, exactly. So this was the payoff, is that we can make it where if we do it this way, the product is much cooler because we don't have to stick to the compass directions and things. And everyone's got it exactly standardized. Those are the pros. The con is that if ever we were to do a reset, anyone who's got one would have to buy new panels, which is gonna be a feeling a bit well, it feels a bit wasteful as well. You know, you've only used them for one set. That's probably gonna feel a bit wasteful, unless they could come up with a way of putting like a kind of fascia over existing panels, I don't know. But that is a bit of a shame. But I think the way to get around it is focusing so much on making a board that's got longevity in the holds and the way that the the friction is on the holds, means that it should last a long time. And I said to Ben at the start, I think you should just make the commitment, we are not gonna do a reset for at least five years on this. Because I was thinking if I was buying one, I'd be stressed that I'm gonna buy one and then you're gonna do a new set, and then suddenly I've got a defunct old product. So I think I think that's what he's gone for. He didn't listen to many ide of my ideas, but I think I think he went with that one.

SPEAKER_01

It's fascinating because it's a big departure from their current business model, where really how Moon seemed to generate more income. And I I don't have any insight into this, and you probably don't either. But yes, they sold new boards, but really what they sold were new holds. And so then you had like a new layout and you had new holds alongside that. So the board stayed the same, but there was new hold sets that got released and had different layouts, and so this depends solely on just new board sales. That's interesting. That that's that's no joke.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, yeah, no joke. And and the other thing you always have to decide when you're doing a new setup is that you're gonna divide your customer base. You know, you're gonna split your customer base apart, and suddenly that number of boards might get halved, say, every time you do it. So it's risky every time you do make it different as well. And people will come in and be like, oh, I hate this set. And then, you know, you saw the the time when when Moon tried to launch the 2024 set, there are people in the comments saying this looks like shit. Like people were saying this is rubbish, this doesn't look like a moon board, it looks like a kilter board. And because the holes were white, besides that, I'm not sure what the similarity was. But then you had Ben entering the comments himself and fighting with individual commenters, and it all descended into a bit of a farce. But like nowadays, and going back to what we were saying earlier, you need a board and you need a Michael. You know, essentially now you need to find yourself a PR guy to make some magic. Now we need both, and I don't think it will work to just have obviously, my you know, Michael can't work with something that's terrible. If it's crap, people are gonna see it's crap. But it needs to be good and you need a Michael to sell it. And I think that's the only way now boards are gonna be successful, and now the pressure is gonna be how do we try and get some of these moon sprays out there? Because when we do, or if we do, hopefully when we do, it's gonna be a great product. But until there's 10, 20 out there, it obviously is gonna be limited.

SPEAKER_01

Well, they don't have a Michael, but are you trying to get a sponsorship going here? They could have a Sam.

SPEAKER_00

No, no, no, so well, but I mean they already do have me. I mean, I come for I basically come for free. I mean, they barely, barely pay me anything. Um, but uh they do now. So um they have just hired uh Teresa to do a little bit of the Michael role, and she's really good, much more organized.

SPEAKER_01

What's her last name? I don't know if I recognize it's Coim Coimbra.

SPEAKER_00

She's I I'm not sure quite how to pronounce it, but um, and I I I hate to describe uh a woman by their partner.

SPEAKER_01

Am I gonna have to edit this out or you can No, no, not at all.

SPEAKER_00

She she won't mind it because she's she's probably better known as Will Bosey's fiance. Oh, okay. She's probably best known for that. And you know, obviously she's her own person, and she's very good. Uh and I think she'll do she'll do exactly what Moon needs, which is a little bit of that kind of professionalizing and pushing the marketing and and kind of like tightening up on that because we've all we've all got to do that now in climbing. Like, you know, there's got to be a little bit of a tightening of the screw, and and I I congratulate Michael really for being the person who I think, well at least I credit with making it, so all the rest of us have to do it.

SPEAKER_01

One of the tips I have for selling something, I guess this goes beyond climbing, but I really see it in Michael, and you know, I I see this with Ben uh as well, Ben Moon, is when you really love the thing that you made, and you just have this deep belief that if everyone else knew what you knew that they would buy it, in some ways, like that's makes sales easy. You're just like, just I like I'm not lying to you. Like, I love this, I know you would love it too. Like that, you know, you can feel that authenticity where they're really proud of it. They're not trying to trick you, they're just like, I'm proud of this, I know you'll love it, like that's why you should buy it. Not please buy it, like I just need to make some money. It's like they deeply love the thing they created. And you know, it's just a good tip for anyone when making content, when selling something, just like if you don't really believe in it deeply, well, that's not fun. You do not want to be a sales job for something that you don't, you do not want to sell something that you don't like yourself.

SPEAKER_00

No, exactly. Did you did you hear the podcast we did with Michael? Yeah, yeah, I did. It was great. Any thoughts? Any takeaways?

SPEAKER_01

Well, you were uh kind of mean to my good friend, uh Michael Rosado, who uh is a good, awesome guy. And he he handled it with a plum. He was uh professional and then some um but I thought you could have been a little nicer to him at just one part. There was just one part which I could make you remember.

SPEAKER_00

I'm I'm I'm sort of offering myself up on a plate here because I deserve a bit of a schlacking. Um to give the context for anyone who's not heard the episode, um, sometimes the funny thing about making a podcast is the worst thing you can do is remember that you're making a podcast. If you remember that you're actually trying to make the thing that you're making, it makes you panic and you try and make it good.

SPEAKER_01

Whereas you're making me panic right now. You're doing it.

SPEAKER_00

Whereas before that point, you're just having a chat, and that's the product, and that is what podcasting is. But I fell into the trap of I started to worry that I've been talking to this Michael chap, and I brought him on because I thought he would disagree with a lot of my takes and we would have some contrast there. We kept agreeing on everything, and I started to panic that this is going to be the world's most boring podcast, as it's just someone saying, I think this, and two other people going, yes, I agree, and I think this, and I agree with that. And I was like, This is rubbish. So I panicked. I told him his product was shit at 30 degrees. I that did happen. Um, I don't actually think that, uh, but that did happen. And what was funny is that I found that so funny when I was doing the editing that I panicked so much. And my favorite bit was Aiden trying to bail me out and me being like, no, I'm doubling down. Um and yes, it it looked quite embarrassing on my on my behalf. And uh I had quite a lot of people message in or comment or something to say, like, man, that was so cringe when Sam asked that question and was like completely fell on his face. Like, and I just had to I had to laugh because it's like, don't forget, I do the edit. Not only did I fall on my face so hard in that moment and and probably panicked and said something very stupid, but also I found it so funny that I left it in, which I think so so. If anything, I deserve criticism twice. So yeah, come come at me, Josh. I deserve, I'll take my punishment.

SPEAKER_01

I I mean, I think it was good that you put in that extra little breaking down the fourth wall or whatever it was, where you're like, look, maybe I didn't, maybe I was a little brutal here. Uh, but it is funny how if you try to invent something, it it does somehow ruin the whole thing you're doing. Like if you try, you you reach for some a villain character or something to disagree on, or something to like make it more interesting, how that like upsets what you're actually doing in the first place. And I want to tell you that it was not boring uh in the beginning. I thought like the diving into classics versus benchmarks, and you know, I found it like really, really interesting. And I loved, I I don't know, I loved the whole I'm like listening. I think I was like texting you at the time. You're like, oh, just wait till you get to this part. I was like, what are you talking about? I heard it.

SPEAKER_02

I thought, oh that's a little speech guy.

SPEAKER_01

Uh uh, and Aiden was very professional. Aiden uh just he tried to rescue, he threw you that lifeline, and you said, No,

Hot Takes That Will Get Us Cancelled

SPEAKER_01

I am drowning, and I'm gonna just go even deeper and be, yeah.

SPEAKER_00

But yeah, I know it was it was a huge, it was a huge own goal. And I think the thing that people find funny really was that it was so bad and it made me look so bad, and yet I left it in the edit. And I think it's because like for me, it was almost the funniest and best moment of the podcast because it was me as a clown falling over, and my hope was that it would make most people laugh. I think some people found it like cringe humour and just found it painful for everyone involved, but at least a few people would make would it would make you laugh. And I do think that's what I'm essentially trying to do podcasting, is that you know it's great every now and then if we can make each other think and ponder, but I guess in my heart of hearts, I'd rather make people laugh, even if it's at my my expense. It's just all you can do, isn't it? And I think don't take me too seriously. Actually, a lot of the takes I come out with I have only just thought of in the moment that I'm saying them. So when the time comes, if when I have to listen to it back, and this is my eternal punishment for being like this, is I edit my own podcast. So I have to listen to myself saying things that are wrong or I don't fully believe in all the time. And that's that's my punishment. But I'm trying to sometimes, sometimes I'm trying to generate a little bit of a conversation, and to do that, you have to say something that you sort of only semi-believe to try and edge out, and and sometimes you get it wrong and you overstep, like I did then, and you say something that you don't really believe at all to try and get a rise out of someone, which is just podcasting. But I'm not a professional. There've there've been no lessons, Josh. No one's taught me how to do this.

SPEAKER_01

If you uh are too careful about the things that you say and worry about, then not only do you basically make something just boring and even and you know, kind of nothing, you also hurt your own thinking. I think you gotta be careful about you you start not even thinking about things in an interesting way or allowing yourself to really shine through. So there's that. Uh, but now I want to give you the mic to uh tell me a very hot take that could get you canceled. Just here's your chance, dude. You could just like what's your hot take on boards? Just give me your the the the sword of Damocles maybe swinging, but you're gonna attempt fate anyways.

SPEAKER_00

Okay, here's here's a really hot let's think of a hot take. Um I've something I've been thinking about recently is I think I'm I'm worried that potentially at some point comp climbers could become the only climbers that matter out of fear that all the rock climbers are on PEDs. So we spoke to Ollie about peptides, and this was really funny because Ollie was quite, you know, he's quite careful and he's really on it and he's very like scientific and everything. And he said, Could you send me a list of questions that you're gonna ask? Because he wanted to knock it out of the park. You know, Ollie really knows his stuff. He wanted to brush up, kind of like Huffy. Huffy's the same, like they want to get it right because they're proper science people. Now I pretend to know about some stuff, but they actually know some stuff. Um, and then the moment he arrived, like within about three seconds of saying hello, I started asking about peptides, which I've not told him was coming. But like a lot of people have reached out to me to say so-and-so's on this, so-and-so's on that, that's banned by Wada, this climber I know is on it, or whatever. And I think this could become an issue if it becomes something that is just generally accepted that the rock climbers are on stuff that's banned by Wadder and the comp climbers aren't because they're getting tested. I fear a time where people might be like, Well, I don't really care what that rock climber's doing, so I don't know what he's on. And I think we could have, here's the hot take I think we could have a movement where rock climbers have to voluntarily take drugs tests.

SPEAKER_01

I think it's the opposite where I think that people don't actually care if people are on stuff.

SPEAKER_00

You think you just did oh you think I mean, didn't we talk about this?

SPEAKER_01

Where we had that clip where it was like we'd like Will uh Will Bosey even more if we knew he was just shooting tons of gear just choosing that one got me. That would love that one. Uh I uh I I watch uh I this sounds weird, but I'm a big fan of Olympic weightlifting. I don't know, you know, it's like the snatch and the cleaning of the jerk. I don't know why, but I'm really fascinated by that sport. Really?

SPEAKER_00

Come on, I think that'd be like wishing paint dry, isn't it? I did it's the best paint ever dry. Um I don't know why really misty-eyed.

SPEAKER_01

You're in the bogus monotage. Um and they are in the Olympics. Um they are all on drugs. They are all on oh, I I would I would bet a great sum of money that 99 out of 100 are on some sort of steroids. They probably cycle off for testing, they're popped for it all the time. It's it in fact, if I remember correctly, weightlifting, they were talking about taking it out of the Olympics because they just had so many drug problems. Like it was just everyone was getting popped for drugs. Uh, and if you look at the weightlifting results now compared to like the 80s, they're not near as good as they used to be because they're not on as many drugs. But with that said, everyone's on drugs there. Wow. And this is the sport you like watching. Yeah, interesting. Well, well, well, but I don't like watching it because they're on drugs. I think my point is that all we really love to see is excellence and just people doing things that are amazing, and we don't care what the cost is to those people that were watching.

SPEAKER_00

Okay, so I'm gonna I'm gonna come but I'm gonna come back at you now. I'm gonna Michael Rosotto you again with I'm gonna give you a second swing. Okay, so maybe the viewers don't care, but it's not still not a great situation if we've got the rock climbers in a position where it's like, well. That person, like I've seen the amount of testosterone that girl's taking, say, uh you can't do what she's doing unless you do it too, or you at least you fear that that's the case. Maybe she wasn't, maybe she wasn't taking anything, but you felt she was, so you started, and then you started, so she did because you were, and she had to keep up with you. And it kind of spirals. Like, maybe the best way to cut all this out is to insist. Okay, well, let's say all heavily sponsored rock climbers, you should just be able to say, This is my water certificate, and we'll try and save, save out all our rock climbers from an arms race, which is going to be so detrimental to their health.

SPEAKER_01

Let me be very clear here that I'm not saying that it's good that people do drugs or that that scenario doesn't exist where you're talking about. And as a as a parent now, I just think to myself, gosh, like the last thing I want is for my kids to look up to someone, want to be like them, and then do steroids with the hope that they might perform like them because they're on steroids.

SPEAKER_00

Like, I'm not saying because you're because you're worried about the cost of steroids and having to buy it all. And yeah, it's expensive, you know.

SPEAKER_01

And it's the money, it's not the how many needles do you need? Yeah, I mean, who cares about uh their health, but the money, the money. Um yeah, and and so I'm not saying this is a good outcome, I'm but I also think it would be a mistake to to not acknowledge that that's the direction things always head. And another example is uh do you ever on the other side of the spectrum of sports I love? Do you ever watch uh mountain biking or specifically Red Bull Rampage? Do you know what that is?

SPEAKER_00

No, I don't know. I feel like our Venn diagram of sports aren't intersecting much, except climbing, Josh.

SPEAKER_01

I'm all over the place. Um they it's a mountain bike uh uh competition, and they create their own jumps and things like that going down a big uh kind of mountain in Utah. And the jumps are insanely big and dangerous to the extent that I remember last year this guy tried to huck a double backflip off and he was paralyzed. He might even be quadruplegic, at least paraplegic. Um, and people just break femur, they just get wrecked, and you know, there's this push that's like, hey, you guys are putting the limelight on these people, and you're there's money involved, and you're asking them to impress and to go big. Like, aren't you basically forcing people into scenarios that are super dangerous? Um, which is different than steroids, but it's the same where it's like from the limelight and the incentives that uh happen in the sport, you're incentivizing people to take great risks. And I guess my my pushback as someone who was an athlete and who likes doing dangerous things as well, to be honest, you can't stop me or them. They don't go big because they want to be famous, they go off of jumps because they like going off big jumps. You can't stop someone from doing steroids to perform the best they can because it's bad for them. They just want to be the absolute best athlete they can be, their health be damned, their risks be damned. Like I just think that you have to acknowledge that that's the path that athletes choose. I'm not saying we should open it up and let everyone do steroids, but I also don't want to ignore that like that's what people are gonna do. Like they're always looking for an edge, always.

SPEAKER_00

That's interesting. So it's basically it's not even, yeah. I see, I see that I see the argument you're making, which means it just begs the question as a parent, doesn't it? Is it just makes you feel very different if you had a child who was like, oh, I want to be a professional climber or something. If you were thinking that that is gonna come with having to take some stuff and push your body to a very dangerous degree, like that would be pretty sad, wouldn't it? It would have to really make you rethink how encouraging you you're gonna be about that life path.

SPEAKER_01

Well, my hot take is that I do not want my kids to be professional athletes. I think the professional athlete life is terrible in almost every sport you can imagine. I I'm I've seen it, you've seen it, maybe you have a different take, but I I think it's not not a great life to live, uh, in my opinion.

SPEAKER_00

I agree. No, I totally agree. Um I think Stephen Fry said not that long ago, uh, this is good, actually, isn't it? Should I do another intro? Uh this is test piece board talk. Uh the topic of the day is kids on steroids. Um uh so uh it was yeah, Stephen Fry was talking about people in sport, and he was like, the patron saint of sports people should be Achilles, because he was uh you know famously given the choice of you can go to Troy, become heroic, everyone will remember your name, but your life will be short. And that's essentially what you're asking as a sports person. And like, you know, if you look at the comp climbers, you get your moment in lights where you're the absolute hero, everyone's chanting a name, but then at some point you're gone, and there's a new person whose name's in light, and everyone chanting their name. People don't really care that much about ex-comp climbers. You know, I I can't remember the last thing I heard from Killian Fisher, for example, and he was the man, he was the man, he was he was absolutely the king, but now there's a new king, and people don't keep up with the old ones. You know, if you st if comp climbing is your game and you're not gonna try and convert to rock climbing, which perhaps you should, but if you're not, you are gonna have to move on and get another job. Like people aren't going to buy stuff that you're selling them when there's a new king and you're you're gone. I I think and I think that's something that you just kind of have to accept going into sport. It's a huge, it's a huge I think and it's something that it's the pull of it is too much, isn't it? You know, if I could have been a comp climber, I would have been. You know, if I could have won World Cups, I would have done it. What a moment that would be.

SPEAKER_01

I I think that whatever we say about, you know, let's say it does require drugs to compete at the highest level in like Olympic weightlifting or whatever, probably climbing at some point. I think that's probably going to be a reality. Gosh, that's gonna that could get me in trouble there. That one could get me that that sword of Damocles just swung one notch lower.

SPEAKER_00

Um that's what I'm here for, Josh. I'm trying to get you cancelled, and then I'm gonna take all of your listeners. Okay.

SPEAKER_01

Um I think you can't if if your kid is driven, but you just can't stop them. You can say whatever you want, you can caution them. You look at guys, they you know get hurt, you know, break their leg, you know, fall off of a tall problem, and then the really driven ones are just back the next time. And this goes back to something what we were saying about strength is uh an important part of climbing, and it, you know, you look at someone like Matt Mendez, and perhaps like he has the strength potential to be one of the best climbers in the world, but does he have the desire to climb hard such that he will endure years and years under the same boulder problem, getting injured? Like to be the best at something, you have to not only have the genetic potential, but then just this absolute insane willingness to pursue whatever you're doing at all costs with total disregard for health, safety, relationships, a normal life. And I guess my my point is there is that you can't stop those people. Like the people who want to be the best, like they don't care. Oh, you're gonna have to get another job after you know you're win the world cup. They're like, who cares about the future? All I'm doing is this. I don't care about the future. I'm in it 100%, 110%. I will do whatever it takes. And I also really admire that, to be honest, Sam. Yeah, also I mean kind of a little jealous of that monomaniacal focus.

SPEAKER_00

It is it is hard not to be not to be impressed by it. And um, you know, we one of the jokes that we've got uh on Keller's talk is that I've never client, I've never tried anything more than 10 sessions. Um, and so I've not achieved what I could achieve, and you've not achieved what you could achieve just by the fact that we haven't put in the Exodia 200 sessions, you know, and that's what you have to do to to find where your limit is. But I've said, just as you're kind of alluding to there, that it's very possible to have a strong body and a weak mind, you know, and you need to have both. Uh, and actually, if you're gonna have one or the other, I think having a strong mind actually edges out at the end. Um that sounds very gateka, doesn't it? But um, I think that's kind of that's how I feel about it. And I think you know what we were saying about that uh um, you know, with Exodia is that there was a lot of people trying to say, oh yeah, he's really, really strong, he's really, really good, you know, he's he's one of the strongest guys out there. He doesn't necessarily need to be. If you put in 200 plus sessions, you don't necessarily need to be the strongest climber to have to have climbed the hardest boulder in the world. Because that that is a sort of you know Martin Keller-esque siege, which most people aren't capable of. You know, I can I couldn't do that, I couldn't dream of doing that. I'd go out of my mind.

SPEAKER_01

What's interesting is that if you are just to go back to the strong mind versus strong body, let's say you're gifted, you know, you are have great genetic potential, you're just amazing, you start competing in your little local league and you just crush everyone instantly without trying hard. You might go along doing that for a while and then you get to the national level. Maybe you're still really good and it's easy for you, but somewhere along your journey, you will have to get beat down and rise from the ashes and put in the hard work. I don't care if you're the most gifted person in the world, it still requires you to not just skate on your genetics, you have to you know hit that wall and then push past it through hard work and determination. And that's just a requisite, like no matter what. So, in some ways, like if you hit that wall early, actually, I feel like maybe Dave McLeod said this in his book. Just like if you get if you aren't in a habit of doing well and you just think, I always have to put in extra work, I always have to be determined, that will carry you through to the end where sometimes people are gifted, and then all of a sudden, instead of being the big fish in the small pond, they look around and they're like, Oh, I'm not that good anymore. Like I was good until I hit the national stage or the world stage, and now I'm just uh just like everyone else. And that's like when champions are made. Like, you know, what do you do in the face of it not being easy anymore?

SPEAKER_00

We had a chat with um uh Louie and Joel, who recently wrote a book um about sort of the mental is very much a self-help psychological book for climbers. Yeah, and I think they kind of meant it in a sort of inner game of tennis style way where it didn't really, you don't really have to be a tennis player to get a lot out of that. I think they meant it that you wouldn't have to be a climber to get out of this uh this book. Um, but one of their core theses I actually sort of disagreed with, which was that they felt like it wasn't mutually exclusive to get your absolute maximum potential and be a hundred percent happy. I'm not sure I agree with it, and I'm interested to hear what you think. I think to get a hundred percent out of yourself, you can't be uh necessarily a hundred percent happy.

SPEAKER_01

Oh, this is so loaded with so many ways you could take it. I I'm gonna share something I just talked to Tom, Tom Randall about, who you also had on the podcast right before me, and we tried not to do that. But um sorry. Sorry, all you listeners who had to listen to. Two excellent episodes, I'm sure. Two excellent okay. Um I talked about this uh scene or uh chapter in Arnold Schwarzenegger's autobiography called uh total recall, which is a great, great name for it.

SPEAKER_00

God, you love this weightlifting stuff, don't you?

SPEAKER_01

I don't know, man. I just like I really like strength. You know, this is maybe one of my downfalls in climbing is I covet strength.

SPEAKER_00

Like I like strength, which is not what hard climbing is, man. That was exactly the same as Malk Smith, I might say. His thing was exactly the same.

SPEAKER_01

I've learned, I I've I've learned to embrace not just strength, but yeah, especially as I get older now. And but maybe that's maybe it's time to get on the drugs, get back that strength. Okay, okay. Um Schwarzenegger made some comment around when he was doing push-ups and it got really hard, how that burn, that intensity, that tiredness made him excited because he knew it was one step closer to his goals. That the direct, the discomfort he was feeling, the the pain of what he was doing, made him happy because he linked it to the outcome that he was looking for. And so my point there is that I could argue that it should overlap your happiness and your ability 100%, because you need to frame what you're doing always in terms of where you're going, and that every action should be aligned with that goal that you're headed towards. And so, by that definition, if you like that goal you're heading towards and you covet it, all of your actions that are in service to it are enjoyable because you're aligned with that, and that anytime there's a discontinuity or discongruency between your action and the goal, that's where you experience pain. You're like, oh, I shouldn't have had a beer with my friends because you know, now I'm not gonna be world champion or something. Um, and again, that monomaniacal focus, like somehow like you get joy out of beating your head against you know the boulder, even though you somehow made backwards progress, but you know it's one step closer somehow.

SPEAKER_00

So, okay, I'm gonna invoke the specter of my high school debate teacher here. Um uh debating champion, by the way. Um wow. To the surprise, to the surprise of nobody. I mean, obviously it's it comes from that in I'll put that in my intro next time. High school debate champion. Yeah, you definitely should see because I've completely just made it up. Um that's not even true. Anyway, um, but what I would uh say there is that I think if you're saying you're gonna be 100% happy because you're making a step towards your goals, it's also you're accepting the fact that you're not 100% happy with where you are currently. You know, you think you're on the road to the utopia that you're aiming for, which I imagine is unreachable, by the way. I think that will constantly, those goalposts will always be somewhere at the end of the rainbow. But you are accepting that you're not 100% happy with where you are now. You'll be happy when you get there. I don't think you can have both those things. And I might be wrong, and obviously Joel is uh, you know, he's he's got degrees in this. So this is me arguing with someone with much more um credentials than me, but that never puts me off. I've got school of life, mate. That's that's even better. Uh I think I just think those two, like sort of philosophical standpoint, I don't think those two things can be true, and it doesn't pair up with my human experience. Like, I think at times when I've desperately wanted to be better and I've been pushing really hard, I've been probably some of the least happy I've ever been because I'm trying to get somewhere that I'm not at.

SPEAKER_01

Oh dude, this is so esoteric and philosophical. Because what you're basically invoking is this idea that by having a goal, you basically are making a contract with yourself that you won't be happy until you get that goal. Like you're you're basically making you're putting yourself in a state of unhappiness because you're saying, I lack, I am devoid of this thing. So by definition, I'm not whole or happy or complete until I achieve it. Until it is happening. Exactly.

SPEAKER_00

Exactly. And in a sense, isn't that exactly what we do with every single climb we ever want to climb? We trick ourselves into that position where we think things will be better when we have done the thing.

SPEAKER_01

Yes. And then you get to the top, and all you can think about is like for me, it's like somehow I've now earned the right, like I climb a new grade. Like, oh, I did this new grade, and then all of a sudden I get to the top. I'm like, well, that means that I can do this problem, maybe because it's of this grade. Like, and all I think about is what's next. Like there's literally, I don't have even a moment of happiness of completing the climb. All I do is just set myself up with another lack, you know, with with with a another goal and that treadmill, dude.

SPEAKER_00

Exactly. And that's that's the fundamental problem with the human condition. Uh, you know, and and I know this wasn't on our board talk list, but essentially, you know, it's trying to. Did you even read the outline? Jeez. I actually didn't read it completely. Uh, but the the idea that you know, we you have to try and recognize the good old dimes while you're still in them, you know, the good old days while you're still in them. You have to try and enjoy what you've had. And I, you know, I remember saying this to Zach Galler when he was on that absolute tear. It's like, do you fall into the trap? And Aidan was saying the same thing because he's just done distillery and now he's looking to try and do six degrees. Do you fall into the trap of being like, if only I can do the next thing, I'll be happy. But if you rest on one's laurels and say, Well, I'm happy with what I've done, which is what my inclination would be, you don't get the next success. You know, so I think the person who constantly says, I'm not happy with that, I want more, I'm not happy with that, I want more, succeeds more than someone who is happy with what they've done, which would be me. You know, if I ever go out on to do a boulder, if I do the boulder on that day, I normally don't try anything else, even if I did it first go. Because I'm happy, I've had a good day, and I don't I don't need to ruin it.

SPEAKER_01

So the the funny thing is that there's an assumption that you're making that doing the boulder is still the prerequisite there for happiness in that moment and that you're trying to enjoy that success. And I have kind of a counter-argument against that and an example. Uh, I I went to South Africa and got to climb at the in Rocklands, and it was a blast. This is like 10 years ago. And I had some Jimmy Webb type of fancy where I thought that I could flash device. And bear in mind I had only done a few uh 8Bs and only flashed up to V11 or 8A. So, like, not so sure that that was realistic, but I'm, you know, I'm an optimistic young man. And somehow I don't even get on the vice until like the last night of the trip, uh, which probably like wasn't the best idea. Um, but I thought, hey, I'm in shape. Actually, I have a pretty good flash go. Get reasonably close. Um, uh reasonably close being like I may have passed that first hard part, but you know, that like under cling move, and yes, it's hard right there. Um, and also just to be truthful, like just because I if I was stuck, a lot of people fall on those last few moves because it's so pumpy and long that probably wasn't that close. Whatever. Um I proceed to uh try it quite a few times, go deep into the night, have my crew with me that somehow supported me on uh late night. And Sam, I tried so hard, dude. Like, I don't know if I've ever tried that hard in my life. Oh, actually, I can think of another couple of ones, but I tried as hard as I could. I literally left it all out there and I didn't I didn't do the boulder, and I've never been back, never done the vice. Um, but when I think back to that time, I like feel really good about that experience in that boulder. Like I literally gave it my all and I'm happy. Like I uh I didn't do the boulder, but I'm somehow like deeply satisfied because I put every ounce of effort that I had in my body and mind. And when you've given it all and the chips fall where they fall, not sending. I'm like, yeah, well, on to the next.

SPEAKER_00

Did you enjoy that at the time as a young man? Did you enjoy that? Because because I I found that I am able to enjoy that feeling so much more now that I'm older, and I could never enjoy that when I was young. I think when I was young, it was a complete binary case of if I did it great, if I didn't bad. Now, I've had a few examples, you know, even relatively recently, where I've just given it everything, come up short, but just been like, man, I'm so glad I tried so hard and I and I have nothing left. There's a real honor in that, isn't there? There's a real honor in being like, I absolutely 100% can't do it now. I've given it everything and I've got nothing left to give. And I'm glad that I drained the tank and I was capable of draining the tank completely. But I don't think I enjoyed that as a young man.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, the reason why I chuckled too is I'm it's like very easy to look back on something and ascribe some kind of morality or philosophical state to it. And then if you were to transport back to, you know, your younger self, it's completely not true. Like it's just you know, it's just looking back with rose colored glasses. I was actually just like, you suck, what are you doing? Like you are a terrible climber. Uh so I I want to be careful about ascribing some kind of deep uh moral and uh perfect foresight into 30 or 28 year old Josh that may not have been. There. But I I kind of remember being defeated, but feeling like I gave it my all. And just I I guess this goes back to my thing about probably not being geared towards being one of the best in the world, regardless of whether physicality I may or or may not possess, is that I think what I really like in climbing is that strength that like I put it all out there. And when I've put it all out there, and you know, I I feel pretty satisfied. Um, and you know, maybe I should be looking more into tweaking technique and waiting for conditions, and that the really important part is sending, is getting to the top. But I don't know, like I get a lot of satisfaction out of just giving it my all. Um, and yeah, that's bad advice for for the young client. It's like, don't listen to me. I'll get to the top.

SPEAKER_00

I agree. And I but I love also that you've set yourself up for someone to publish a counter memoir. And this is what happened to one of our early guests a long time ago is that they had a story exactly like this. And then I had a very funny message from someone who came in to be like, I was on the trip with that person, and they were absolutely insufferably grumpy the entire time and ruined it for all of us, and we'd never go on a trip with them again. Hmm, that is quite different from the story they told. But you know, that's another part of getting older and looking back a long time, isn't it? Is we like to maybe think it was slightly different and we do think a bit rosily. But yeah, I think that's very precocious of you if you were able to think like that in the moment. But yeah, I can only enjoy it now.

SPEAKER_01

Well, I think it's good when you're thinking about advice or like the reality of the world and how to set yourself up for success. I sometimes think about what would I tell my kids? And the reason why that's important is because you know, you don't know what the outcome will be for others. And so ideally, your advice will just set them down the path, but you can't guarantee success. You can't say, if you do this, you will be world champion. Right? Like you that you know, you can't guarantee anything. And so if you tell someone, hey, really give it your all. Like put every if you want to do something, put all your effort out. And if if you win, great. If you don't, that's okay too, because you had nothing left. I I feel like that's good advice. Uh and the truth is we can't all be Adamandra or Aiden.

SPEAKER_00

And statistically, you're not going to be Adamandra or Aiden. You know, it's like, you know, like there is only one of those people. So statistically, you're not going to be Yanya. So you're gonna have to make your peace with that at some point because only Yanya is Yanya, and you're not uh So I asked this question, you know, how you go from good to great.

SPEAKER_01

And and my the reason why I'm always fascinated in that is it's one thing to be a World Cup competitor, it's another to be Yanya. Like, what is that difference? And I have I had AJ on here. Do you know Alex Johnson? I don't know if you ever had her on.

SPEAKER_00

She's I know who she is, but I've never spoken to her.

SPEAKER_01

Wonderful woman, great competitor, top of the game for a long time. She's yeah, got gold medals and worlds, she's great. Um I ask her that question, and you know, you're looking for some like advice that maybe you could tell your kids or something, something to help people along. And she goes, genetics. Yeah, just it was like a one-word answer. It was just like either you were built for it or you weren't. And if you're not, tough luck. You know, I was just like, ooh, rough.

SPEAKER_00

But in a sense, that's why you asked the question, isn't it? Is because and and you know, this is a slight spoiler for anyone who's listening to your podcast, uh, hoping to get that question answered. Nobody knows the answer to that question. It's different for everybody, and it's interesting to hear people trying to answer a question which is completely unanswerable. We don't know how to get from good to great. You're not gonna find that out no matter how many times you ask it. But it's that's why it's worth asking. You know, you can ask everybody that same question because no one's gonna tell you the answer. If someone told you the answer, then you'd have to stop asking the question.

SPEAKER_01

So here's my answer after talking to a lot of people and being inspired by a specific book. It's called The Art of Learning. This guy, Joshua Waitskins, and he's done some great podcasts too. Really liked him. Um and he talks about the difference between being number fifth in the world and first in the world, is often that it's your unique ability and authenticity truly shining through, and that sometimes you have to unlearn what is uh typically correct and got you to that point to be able to exhibit your own specific excellence and it's often different from what the conventional advice is. And this is me pointing out Aiden overpowering things, right? Like going slow. This is uh, you know, Dave Graham just doing the most crazy sequences and relying on finger strength and toe hooking. And, you know, you think like, what if you just did a bunch of one-arm pull-ups, dude? And it's like no, to be great is to really lean into what makes you you and do it at a level that literally no one else in the world can do. And so that's why that uh the answer to that question doesn't exist because it's all a unique journey that each of those people have gone on, and they had to almost unlearn what everyone else does and thinks are is important, and lean into some kind of uh deep belief in themselves and expressing it in their own unique way. And that's what makes them literally the best in the world.

SPEAKER_00

I think for me at heart, I think what's a question that's more interesting from how to go from good to great is whether you actually want to go from good to great, whether you are actually prepared for the sacrifice that that will take. And in my opinion, some of the happiness and the many, many amazing things in life you will miss out on in your you know, pursuit of greatness. I think the real question should be do you want to? I know you think you want to, but do you really want to? Please make that the question that you ask every guest.

SPEAKER_01

Just be like, Do you even want to go from good to great? I know you were just on that that that crappy test piece podcast talking about, but do you even want to?

SPEAKER_00

Why are you even here? Oh, it's not crappy, Josh. It's the second best climbing podcast out there. You know, Sam, if it's gotta be second best to someone, I'm happy it's you guys.

SPEAKER_01

Um I I uh I think it is uh interesting question, uh support for it goes back again to the to the to the to the drug use, to the uh danger. You can't stop those people, Sam. You just can't stop them. That like it's not a question, there is no it that's like that falls on deaf ears, just like I'm sure it would with you as a kid. It's like, hey, Sam, are you sure you want to spend this much time climbing? I used to think about this like if I was as good at um being a hedge fund manager as I am at climbing, I'd be a very wealthy man. Um, and you you know, like if somebody had come along and said, Josh, why don't you put the same effort towards uh, you know, your school, I'd be like, no, like we're even talking, that's ridiculous. Like, this is what I do. And so I just think it falls on deaf ears to say, are you willing to make the sacrifice? To I think to a lot of people, it would be a sacrifice to not pursue that thing, would be my argument.

SPEAKER_00

So here's another thing that I think is interesting, then is that is any answer to that question going to actually influence somebody? Or is it that any yanya out there, once they've found climbing, they're already, it's too late. You know, they're gonna be the best. It's gonna happen no matter what anyone says or what anyone does. The people who are going to be great are just destined for it because it's already within them.

SPEAKER_01

Probably. Probably. Um but what what's rough is that you don't know that you have uh a hundred yanyas coming up and they all are on that path. And then the question becomes like, is there something we can nudge them towards or save them from you know, maybe injurious moves or overtraining or something like is that like what a coach or listening to wise, wise old men like you and the unks uh that can help them, you know, along that that path versus getting derailed. But it it reminds me of this kind of thing around being an entrepreneur and it was like some class on entrepreneurship, yeah, starting your own business, right? Like I wanna and I'm I spent a lot of time in San Francisco where we really covet the founder, the the the innovator, the the person willing to risk their you know neck to to create the next big thing. Um, and we could critique that if we want to, but let's just acknowledge it. And there was a class on that, and the guy who went up and talked to them is like basically he's like, don't become an entrepreneur, do not do this, because the only people who should be an entrepreneur is people who like don't give a shit what I say and just do it anyways. You know, like you can't again, you can't talk them out of it. Like, that's what it takes, is that dedication. So, no, we can't, we uh you can't talk them out of it.

SPEAKER_00

I dread to imagine some of the sort of pathetic crypto bros in the audience at that like you're not gonna be a brilliant entrepreneur. Just give it up, it's not going to happen. No matter how many pictures you take that make it look like you own a Lamborghini, you're not gonna be that guy.

SPEAKER_01

When Chris Sharma did that whole blockchain ad, I just got it's just and dude, Sam. No one loves Chris Sharma more than me. No one loves Chris like that. You know, he's my Michael Jordan. I I've done a lot of podcasts. Getting through a podcast with Chris was my pinnacle. I was more nervous.

SPEAKER_00

It would be mine too. We haven't had him on. It would be my pinnacle. There's no one I could talk to that had a bigger impact on my life in climbing than Chris.

SPEAKER_01

And I am okay with him trying to pay the bills. He's gotta you know find that job after being uh one of the best in the world. It made me a little sad. I I was a little sad. Uh yeah, I think sorry Chris if you're listening. I'm sorry, he wouldn't listen. He dude, Chris is just off being cool. He's on boats, on yachts, trading crypto. I don't know.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, he was he was he was cool, wasn't he? I mean, wicking very unkish, but he was he was our hero. But uh yeah, I mean, I mean he still is really in many ways. But yeah, hearing him say every move is a trade, that that cut a little bit, didn't it? That hurt get get that bad, king.

SPEAKER_01

Sam, I don't want to end on that. Like, can we say something positive? I don't know.

SPEAKER_02

Like, that just needs to be like that makes me a little sad.

SPEAKER_01

I mean, please don't tell me that your next sponsor is a blockchain company.

SPEAKER_00

No, no, I'm I'm I'm I'm just glad we said it at the end because it means statistically the chances of Chris hearing it is in mess because I haven't managed to have him on my podcast yet, and I'd still love to have him.

SPEAKER_01

I mean, the thing about Chris and and I think all all the all the people we always look up to is they're just doing their thing. You know, I don't think Chris is too worried about what we think about him. I don't think Chris's too worried uh about that. And no, I got I'm trying to like I'm trying to justify. I'm trying to I'm trying to put them in the best light. Please, Chris, don't do any more blockchain stuff. Although maybe the joke's on us. What if it was like the best company ever and it like yes?

SPEAKER_00

We just assumed it was a scam because 99% of crypto is, yeah.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, god, maybe we're the ones blowing it.

SPEAKER_00

Um yeah, I lost the money on cryptocurrency once. Yeah, look at wise man of the world. I joke about I junk a bit of the cool age right in the early days. I was like, yeah, maybe there is something in this. And then I got hacked, Josh, and I lost my crypto coins.

SPEAKER_01

You know, one thing that I really try to stay away from in this podcast, despite us talking about PDs and philosophy and self-help books, is I do not want climbing podcasts to be about things other than climbing. I just there's no there's no financial advice here other than don't get hacked if you're gonna do crypto. Like uh and you know, I just whenever I see that happen in podcasts, I'm I'm just I do not want just like I don't want Chris to tell me which crypto coins to buy, I don't want to tell people what you must hate our podcast.

SPEAKER_00

Are you giving financial advice? We try we try and talk about climbing as little as possible on many of our episodes.

SPEAKER_01

I just believe it should be a lens you can you can narrow your lens into climbing and it opens up. I I'm a big fan of of depth. Despite me talking about a bunch of other sports, I used to have a I had a buddy who liked to, he was a good climber, and then he would pick up a new sport. He and he would tell me how he just liked that initial learning curve of sports. Like he wanted to be a jack of all trades. He wanted to like try it all and to be well-rounded as an athlete. And my argument back to him was just if you've never been excellent at something, like you're missing the whole point of sport. Like it's you know, you need to go deep and you need to really understand all the nuances. And and this is something I say about climbing harder. See if you agree with me on this, is uh I think that climbing harder is more fun than climbing easier. Great. I think the reason to get stronger and better at climbing is that it's more interesting, and that I literally had more fun climbing a V10 than a V5. Like it took more out of me, it took more focus. It's not just I got stronger. It's it's everything I find it more interesting. It's a good reason to not just dabble in different things, but to like zero in and have depth in a subject such as climbing.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, and I think that's one of the fun things. Getting older, as long as you're still getting better, is that I can still chase the things that I've been chasing since I started. So the first the things you know, I watched the the films that made meant the most to me, like the between the trees and the stuff with um uh like Keith Bradbury and stuff like that. That was what I was super inspired by. And I have been able to get good enough that I got to climb Gecko Assis, which was the culmination of Between the Trees. I got to and I've been to Fawn and I wanted to climb the low to Gormandies because that was the culmination of The Stranger. Um, and like I've managed to get good enough that I've been able to do the things that wowed me when I started climbing. And yes, everyone else has moved on and they're looking at you know whatever Aiden's doing, or you know, that's you know that's amazing and Adam or whatever, and I but I can't do that, and I'm not gonna catch them. But I like the fact that I can catch who I've been chasing since the start. And I think that is that just makes it so much more rewarding, doesn't it? When you get to be the you get to be the person that was your hero, you get to be them. The heroes now I can't be, but I can be the heroes from you know 12 years ago or something.

SPEAKER_01

What other claims are still left on your lifetime list?

SPEAKER_00

Boogeisen is huge for me. I've never been out to it, and I talk about it often. Boogle, I think my biggest ones in my head, or some of them, the ones that like leap to mind, uh Bugleisen and Big Poor, I think are two that I would just absolutely love to do because they were just huge. Big Island, but unfortunately I can't do it the spanny way, so I'd have to try and figure out some other way, but that would be another one that is just iconic.

SPEAKER_01

I got on the Big Island with Carlo, and I like big compression. You know, we I told you my my stats, we sound similar, you know, around five, nine, six foot. And like there's very few times in my life that I've been like, wow, I'm a little, I'm a little short for this one. And Big Island, I was just blown. Like, I love heel hooking. I love white, like should have fit me. And I was like, wow, this is just a little too big for me the traditional way. And I actually didn't really try it. You know, Carlo was doing the kind of shorter person beta, but uh it's big.

SPEAKER_00

If the big island is big, unfortunately, I think so. Nathan Phillips reckons that we can do it. He's got a similar span to me. But I had the same feeling as you. I only really felt the positions, I didn't try and pull on, but I felt like I was going to be too short for the normal way and too tall for the short person way. But that's just excuses, isn't it? I mean, it's always possible to do it the short person way. Maybe the tall person is impossible, but the short person will just have to be better. Um, and that would certainly be a boulder that would mean a hell of a lot to me if I ever did it. But of the ones I mentioned, that feels the least likely. I think I can do Booge Eyes, and I think I can do the big poor, I can do Big Paul. I don't know if I can do Big Island.

SPEAKER_01

Why do you chase these boulders? Is it literally just the inspiration from you as a kid? Is it aesthetics? Is it movement? Like what really gets you to keep on trying?

SPEAKER_00

Aesthetics means almost nothing to me. I feel like I I care about aesthetics much less than most people. I'm almost like I've got uh uh like a sort of visual blindness of it. You know, I don't seem to, I don't think I see it in the same way. People go, oh wow, what a beautiful boulder. And I just kind of nod along most of the time. Um and go like, I don't really care. Uh I I care about movement, I care about moves, I care about holds, and I care about stuff I've seen and history. I actually don't care that much if the boulder looks good on a postcard. That doesn't, it's never been important to me. You're wrong. It's all about aesthetics. Many, many, many people disagree with me. All the cool people that you look up to, if you're listening to this, they all like aesthetics. I'm very much in the uncool brigade.

SPEAKER_01

It's so fascinating how history plays such a big role in the climes that we seek out. Like just it, it's a big deal for me. I I think uh for me, the the aesthetics and the history are combined in this sense of the climbs that I most covet and want to do are ones that I'm intimidated when I stand under or think about. There's something about just that feeling of an imposing climb, or one that only, you know, only Sharma could do, or something, you know, just like the those things in history where they were the pinnacle when you were young and it just holds this weight, and it's just like you stand under and you're like, who am I? You know, who am I to climb this? Or this is tall and scary. And for me, that overcoming of that, and then getting to that level, to that top, and just being like, I'm the kind of person that can, you know, be intimidated under a roof like this that is 30 feet tall and with no rope and get on top. Like to me, those always like are interweaved of like history, aesthetics, height, like just intimidation is is what really gets me in climbing.

SPEAKER_00

And I I can totally and I I understand it and I like hearing you talk about it because I can imagine it. I don't have it so much myself, but I do I like hearing you say it because I think it's I think it's fun that we all see things differently. And I think if there's one thing I've tried to advocate for slightly, though, it's that just see things the way you see them and then just express that. Don't try and be like, oh, Josh sounds so cool saying that. Next time someone asks me that question, I'm gonna repeat what Josh said. Just say what's true for you. Just just be, you know, I don't see it that way, and I think that's cool that you do, and and I think I would be cooler if I saw it that way, but I don't. So I don't need I I shouldn't try and pretend and sort of massage the figures.

SPEAKER_01

All right, I want to end it here before going on to the Patreon stuff because I gotta do something for the patroons. I'm sorry, that's you. I that's that's not you, although this will go to your patroons as well. If you want to hear that QA and other extra behind-the-scenes content from this episode and others, head over to patreon.com slash test piece to sign up now. Patrons also get their episodes early and ad-free. There's hours and hours of bonus content there to help you on your own path of going from good to great. Still not sure? There's a free seven day trial for you to check it out. And to help the show grow, please share this episode with someone who would love it. Okay, see you next week.